Can a case be made that DMX is better than Nas?

Is DMX a better rapper than Nas

  • Yes

    Votes: 54 16.4%
  • No

    Votes: 275 83.6%

  • Total voters
    329

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,441
Reputation
3,926
Daps
48,313
Reppin
NULL
X fell off because of personal problems not because he couldn't rap anymore.. his case for Top 5 is just as good as Nas

And who has nas reminded of his greatness despite his fans?

That's an excuse. Nas had personal problems as well, but it didn't stop him.
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,441
Reputation
3,926
Daps
48,313
Reppin
NULL
Yes it would. Dying early always helps in hip hop because nobody seen the fall off

No it wouldn't have. Pac and Big weren't elevated due to them dying. It was orher factors. First off, they had the music to support the claims. Second, them making songs and albums that alluded to the death they would die made it easy for people to create this mythology around them when they ultimately did die. They became prophets in the eyes of many. Pac, in particular became a figure that was bigger than rap because people saw him as a revolutionary.
 

feelosofer

#ninergang
Joined
May 17, 2012
Messages
48,910
Reputation
7,439
Daps
138,162
Reppin
Brick City, NJ
I'll say this DMX is a great rapper. Had he not had problems with drugs he's be a top 15 of all time rapper, maybe even top 10 (that's a hard sell). To be honest as beloved as his 1st 3 albums are, none of them are classics (outside of being personal classics). Nas has earned the reputation of being a top rapper of all time. Even though I think he has only 2 classic albums, if you go song by song, Nas has it by a longshot.
 

Shadow King

Quiet N***a Loud Choppa
Supporter
Joined
Oct 31, 2012
Messages
42,370
Reputation
3,375
Daps
85,630
Reppin
Hometown of Cherokee at Law
YCRa34g.gif
Where is this from? :russ: I know it but can't call it
 

Xtz23

All Star
Joined
Feb 3, 2017
Messages
4,433
Reputation
1,961
Daps
8,961
mega beat up nas?

I didn't know they fought.





DMX only had one good year now?:snoop:





yep

along with snoop, if he lost that murder trial.




DMX reached heights that nas couldn't dream of, and he was there for a good 3-4 years. and before the Viacom takeover, the standard run was 3-5 years. the idea that DMX was just lightning-in-a-bottle is usually just post-2000s rap fan rhetoric. when the politics started to dictate everything.

DMX' run was standard length, and actually greater than standard considering everything that he crammed into that window. plus, X still wouldn't have fallen completely out the picture like he did if it wasn't for drugs & def jam.

"if I ruled the world" is just a big-budgeted, yet still watered-down version of AZ "sugar hill". the same AZ that nas basically patterned his career shift after, coupled with the hype machine that AZ didn't have.

aint nothing iconic about stillmatic breh. its not a classic. and it wasn't an album filled with hits neither.





those albums are 4 years apart breh.

they both saved def jam during their respective eras.





ehh. ruff ryders giving the duties to swizz was moreso a mix of nepotism & a low-cost business move.

but yea, swizz was a much bigger hit-maker than dame grease. on the flip, dame was the better choice for holding down a project. we saw it again a decade later with max b & hell rell.

as much as I hate how under-appreciated swizz beatz is on the internet, and in this thread. your disdain for dame grease is no better.:scust:

both producers are great. I bump IDAHIH & FOMFBOMB like a two-mood double-cd.





I stated it poorly.

I moreso meant his top 10 status.

I wasn't trying to say he was doggystyle/snoop dogg status.

Na bro I meant he exposed him on a real level and destroyed him on multiple tracks. Thun and kicko that is probably one of the best diss tracks ever. after that I seen the bytch in nas not just because mega lyrically bodied him but what he was saying was all facts. Nas is a shady character and the shyt he raps bout is him scribbling in his notepad Escpecially on it was written. still one of the goats but that shyt made me look at him differently. Then years go by you realize it wasn't just mega who said nas is a snake there was many others. Dudes a phony.
 
Last edited:

Lifer11

All Star
Joined
Oct 16, 2012
Messages
2,980
Reputation
275
Daps
6,226
Reppin
NULL
And didn't nas have that same window particularly after illmatic where he could have ended this discussion but fell flat on his face?

No, because It Was Written is a great album, I Am... is a very good to great album, Nastradamus was admittedly a dud, Stillmatic is a very good to great album and Nas is still relevant and just as talented to this day.

DMX is in my personal top 5 (favorite not best ever), but he has nowhere near the consistency/longetivity of Nas, and Nas is still the better rapper when comparing both at their peak.

A prime X can hang with anyone in the history of the game, but it was just too short of a prime and too hard of a falloff (to truly belong in the GOAT conversation).
 

T.H.E. Goat

On the road to riches
Supporter
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
14,511
Reputation
3,689
Daps
51,324
Reppin
Where The Grass Is Blue
For this to even be a question is an example of nas having higher expectations...To me I Am and Nastradamus are, from a qualitative standpoint, on the same level as X's first 3 albums...Those are nas' consensus worse projects

Now when considering X after his third album might as not even exist...And Nas has late career gems like Untitled and Life is Good and still blesses the odd feature verse...This is absurd






In terms of rapping how can people front on songs like these?

And these were from one of, if not his worse, album
 

MIAlien

#FactsOnly
Supporter
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
2,284
Reputation
420
Daps
4,565
Reppin
Wade County
DMX is possibly the most overrated rapper of all time. IDGAF what anyone says.

:pacspit:

Nas falling off is 1 of the biggest mtyhs & loads of crap in hip hop history

It started when stupid hip hop purist & media didnt like the direction he went in on IWW with more opulence, mafiaso & kingpin ducktales mixed in with intelligence & he went into it even more on i am

Then you owe me came out & they minds was made up that he had officially fell off even tho he still was selling records & in the pop charts

Nastradamus may be a misstep but how many missteps does dmx have what about jay :what:
It's not a myth. It was a general belief at the time. And the difference between Nas and DMX/Jay is that they were consistently themselves. Volume 3 Jay is still the same guy, even if Volume 3 wasn't as good as Volume 2, 1, or RD.

Nas went from street poet to mafia don. You could tell he was influenced by Biggie and others and started telling first person shooter type of stories. So he lost some of his direction and started following what other people were doing. You Owe Me Nas isn't the same guy as One Love Nas. And a lot of his fans wanted him to stay that guy.

I like both i am and it was written. That whole shyt was started by jay z.:mjlol:
Nah. Stop it. That was a general belief before Takeover. Nas wasn't in the mainstream consciousness by 2001, outside of Oochie Wally, which was a minor song dropped early in the year. It took the Jay beef and Stillmatic to bring him back by the end of the year. He had been cold for a while by then.

And you can tell, because he was everywhere between when Stillmatic and God's Son dropped. He made a comeback.
 

Palm Tree's & Blunts

Big timah timah
Joined
Aug 15, 2015
Messages
5,429
Reputation
756
Daps
14,372
DMX is possibly the most overrated rapper of all time. IDGAF what anyone says.

:pacspit:


It's not a myth. It was a general belief at the time. And the difference between Nas and DMX/Jay is that they were consistently themselves. Volume 3 Jay is still the same guy, even if Volume 3 wasn't as good as Volume 2, 1, or RD.

Nas went from street poet to mafia don. You could tell he was influenced by Biggie and others and started telling first person shooter type of stories. So he lost some of his direction and started following what other people were doing. You Owe Me Nas isn't the same guy as One Love Nas. And a lot of his fans wanted him to stay that guy.


Nah. Stop it. That was a general belief before Takeover. Nas wasn't in the mainstream consciousness by 2001, outside of Oochie Wally, which was a minor song dropped early in the year. It took the Jay beef and Stillmatic to bring him back by the end of the year. He had been cold for a while by then.

And you can tell, because he was everywhere between when Stillmatic and God's Son dropped. He made a comeback.

I was to young to expierence it anyways but it just seems like people run with this whole because jay said it it must be true type shyt.
 

spliz

SplizThaDon
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
61,647
Reputation
9,422
Daps
205,407
Reppin
NY all day..Da Stead & BK..
You don't like a lot of stuff out of 90's as opposed to what? And you don't like Nas especially for what reason?
He's proven in this thread time and time again he doesn't even have the knowledge to make an assessment about the 90s or Nas. He over here talkin to nikkas who forgot more hip hop than he's ever knew.
 
Top