**Breaking News**McNabb is BACK!!

[FTBS]

Warner is one of the top 3-5 playoff quarterbacks in history that's why he's not a choker. Mcnabb can't tie his shoes in that regard.

So the fact that he threw a pick six in a 3pt SB loss TWICE means nothing huh? The fact that he had a clear cut advantage in talent around him means nothing huh? So basically you have just decided McNabb is a choker and Warner is this great playoff QB and nothing, not even facts or logic will change that. Got it.

 

[JLova]

Warner was great...but when did McNabb have that kind of talent around him?

Ricky Proel was a #3 receiver for Kurt. Then he had Boldin and Fitzgerald.

When he had Toomer and Hilliard he became a backup.

 

[Street Knowledge]

How exactly has he choked you piece of fukking garbage? Before you answer, just remember you give Alex all kinds of excuses for having no "weapons". Come tell me how great Thrash, Pinkston, FedEx and LJ Smith were. Come tell me, fakkit.

If I could only scissor kick your head clean off your body through my gotdamn screen, I would.

Mad? Nikka, I'm

10-22 100 yards 3 picks and a 19.3 Rating against Carolina ain't choking? He didn't have good recievers but let's not act like he was lighting it up out there consistently in the playoffs

 

[The War Report]

Warner is one of the top 3-5 playoff quarterbacks in history that's why he's not a choker. Mcnabb can't tie his shoes in that regard.

Did McNabb not go to 4 NFC tittle games?

 

[JLova]

10-22 100 yards 3 picks and a 19.3 Rating against Carolina ain't choking? He didn't have good recievers but let's not act like he was lighting it up out there consistently in the playoffs

So you pick one game? Every QB has had shyt games, you fukking idiot. The greatest QBs have had complete garbage games in the playoffs so spare me on that choke shyt.

Son did a lot with nothing for many years.

 

[havoc00]

Never understood all the hate for him in Philly, shyt was stupid

 

[Piff Perkins]

damn, thought thread title said the McRibb was back

 

[Street Knowledge]

So the fact that he threw a pick six in a 3pt SB loss TWICE means nothing huh? The fact that he had a clear cut advantage in talent around him means nothing huh? So basically you have just decided McNabb is a choker and Warner is this great playoff QB and nothing, not even facts or logic will change that. Got it.

So 2 plays(one in a game where he was brilliant and led gave his team the lead with less then 5 mins to go) judges his whole career? I'm talking about his postseason body of work as a whole, he's one of the all time greats in that regard. The reason why I said Warner is better because he's a vastly superior playoff performer, there not even in the same damn ball park and I never said mcnabb was a choker in the first place

And the "facts" are the playoff numbers and perfomances.

 

[Street Knowledge]

So you pick one game? Every QB has had shyt games, you fukking idiot. The greatest QBs have had complete garbage games in the playoffs so spare me on that choke shyt.

Son did a lot with nothing for many years.

Your getting extremely emotional over a nikka that doesn't even know you

You said how did he choke, and I showed you an example. I've never called mcnabb a choker, but this notion that he was lighting it up in the Playoffs and his teams were failing him is garbage. 50.5 passer rating the first 3 NFC title games

The 09' NFC title game was a masterpiece though

 

[arlowpear]

I just hope he doesn't start hatin on nikkahs...Cuz I can see somebody cookin his azz quick...On second thought that may make for good TV.

 

[superunknown23]

Kurt Warner might be a corny ass evangelical but he was also a vastly superior QB than McNabb... That's why he's going to the HOF.
No comparison.

 

[Tom]

Do NFL players retire jerseys?


if so then Philly needs to retire his, he did so much for the Eagles, its the least they could do for him

 

[FTBS]

So 2 plays(one in a game where he was brilliant and led gave his team the lead with less then 5 mins to go) judges his whole career? I'm talking about his postseason body of work as a whole, he's one of the all time greats in that regard. The reason why I said Warner is better because he's a vastly superior playoff performer, there not even in the same damn ball park and I never said mcnabb was a choker in the first place

And the "facts" are the playoff numbers and perfomances.

Actually he threw the game ending pick in that first SB as well and the refs bailed him out. If it was McNabb those two plays would define him the same way a couple bad passes in the SB still define him to this day.

McNabb did his thing in the playoffs on the regular and without quality weapons for the most part. There is no doubt in my mind that McNabb would've won at least one SB playing with Warners weapons and there is no doubt that Warner wouldn't have done shyt with McNabbs weapons. Warner was a more accurate thrower no doubt however McNabb was the superior playmaker and literally had to carry his teams offensively for the most part. Warner fukkin disappeared for 5 years in between ****, Bruce, Faulk and Fit/Boldin.

 

[Boolean]

if it was for McNabb i wouldn't be a Eagles fan

 

[Rapmastermind]

No white QB with McNabb's resume would receive this much hate. As a matter of fact, he would still be in the league

The funniest part of the Mcnabb hate is the haters don't even realize he's one of the winningst QB's in NFL HISTORY. Only 10 QB's in NFL HISTORY Have won more TOTAL games (Regular Season + Playoffs) than Mcnabb:


TOTAL WINS IN NFL HISTORY (REGULAR SEASON + PLAYOFFS)


1 Brett Favre 186 112 0 + 13 11= 199-123
2 John Elway 148 82 1 + 14 7 = 162-89-1
3 Dan Marino 147 93 0 + 8 10 = 155-103
4 Peyton Manning 141 67 0 + 9 10 = 150-77
5 Tom Brady 124 34 0 + 16 6 = 140-40
6 Joe Montana 117 47 0 + 16 7 = 133-54
7 Fran Tarkenton 124 109 6 + 6 5 = 130-114-6
8 Johnny Unitas 118 64 4 + 6 2 = 124-66-4
9 Terry Bradshaw 107 51 0 + 14 5 =121-56
10 Jim Kelly 101 59 0 + 9 8 = 110-67
11 Donovan McNabb 98 62 1 + 9 7 =107-69-1


So people can hate all they want but only 10 QB's that ever picked up the pigskins won more games than Donovan. If you separate the stats. Regular Season Donovan is 12th All Time and Playoffs he's 11th All Time. He's also Top 20 All time in almost all major QB statistics. He did not have the WR talent that some of the great QB's got to have. He had Westbrook and Duce but he never truely had the power running game cause of Andy's style offense. Also he's in the Top 10 running QB's of all time as far as yards and TD's. Donovan career is so underrated.

He lost some Big Playoff games, sure, but so did a lot of other greats. He lost his only Superbowl to Tom Brady, if you are going to lose, lose to a Legend. He lost 4 NFC title games, yes that horrible but he made it to 5 of them. He had his team in the final 2 of the NFC for half of his career and the Final four of the NFL. Only Brady and Manning can say they won more regular season and playoff games in his era. Matter of face he has a better Playoff record than Peyton. The title game losses were bad, no way to spin it but if you look inside the numbers, he really only played bad in 2 of them (Tampa and Carolina). Against the Rams he went in their house and almost beat the greatest show on turf at home. Against Arizona he again on the road staged a huge comeback but the defense let him down stopping Warner. Overall Mcnabb was the QB over 9 Playoffs wins the most ever for an Eagles QB. Donovan made the Eagles relevant again. He's a Hall of Famer and yes if a White QB had his numbers, they wouldn't be as critized as Donovan is.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Most_wins_by_a_starting_quarterback_(NFL)



NFL starting quarterback playoff records - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia