Of his era, the only guys legitimately above him were:
LeBron
Steph
Durant
Kawhi
AD
Harden
Westbrook
Paul
PG falls in that next tier of dudes of Butler and Dame and Kyrie. So he's pretty easily a Top 12 player of his prime and generation, but being a Top 12 player at your best isn't Hall status to me. Basketball Hall let's everybody in so he has a shot, but if it were my call, you being Top 12 at your best isn't even a conversation starter...
But I will remember how good he was. Indiana PG was one of my favorite players, for some reason he was less likeable once he left Indy, I didn't enjoy really watching him anymore...