Baker Mayfield or Justin Herbert?

Mayfield or Herbert?


  • Total voters
    31

Soldier

not redeemed with gold but with His Blood
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
3,207
Reputation
537
Daps
8,657
Baker for his resilience, hard work, actual results and production on the field
Herbert for his raw talent, strong/accurate arm, athleticism, youth and potential

Baker has a little more experience/savvy/poise than Herbert. Herbert has a lot to learn and has a lot to prove.



Both have big and obvious flaws, that’s why I’m not a fan of either because obviously if I had the choice I would choose burrow/Allen/Jackson/Mahomes instead.

Herbert got the future, but baker for the present moment right now.
 
Last edited:

jdubnyce

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
55,199
Reputation
14,358
Daps
255,947
Reppin
t-dot till they bury me

VegetasHairline

Veteran
Joined
Jun 25, 2012
Messages
39,119
Reputation
15,880
Daps
162,535
Reppin
CACS

premier58

All Star
Joined
Apr 10, 2015
Messages
6,201
Reputation
608
Daps
12,156
I need to see Herbert with two good ass WRs and a good te, at the same time. Then I will judge. But personally, I feel Baker has peaked already and Herbert still has some big time improving to do.
 

Trav

Marathon Mentality 🏁
Supporter
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
32,849
Reputation
6,367
Daps
90,098
Reppin
TMC 8-24
Midbert is the clear option if he could get his head outta his ass. He makes throws not a lot of these young mfs can make but since he also plays like he's gone off that narcotic sometimes, it's closer than what it should be.
 

murksiderock

Superstar
Joined
Feb 12, 2017
Messages
15,333
Reputation
6,701
Daps
47,643
Reppin
SMF and LAX to VA and NC
Baker Mayfield has a whopping 2 playoff wins and was a number one overall pick.
:unimpressed:
That's two more than Herbert and he's just consistently played well in the postseason, even in defeat...

Tampa was supposed to crater, Baker was on a 1-year deal as a bridge QB. Instead, this mf turned into an elite QB who won his division twice...

He's significantly more resilient than Herbert. I dont know that I'd give Herbert much of an edge on athleticism, Baker is fast and fearless, too. He extends plays and is pretty damn accurate...

I want the guy who shows up in the big games. That guy isnt Herbert...
Easily Baker. Justin Herbert is Just A Guy 🤣...
 
Joined
Dec 19, 2017
Messages
15,577
Reputation
4,293
Daps
62,397
Depends.

If you have an elite coach/QB developer (McVay, Reid etc), you take Herbert because the upside is there and he still has a lot of room to grow.

If you have an average/above average coach (McCarthy) and need someone more ready to go NOW....take Baker.
 

FukkaPaidEmail

Retired Hoodrat whisperer
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
23,194
Reputation
4,108
Daps
89,460
Reppin
The Diaspora
baker makes too many mistakes ..Herbert

Herbert makes both teams better

chargers get worse with baker because he’s not gonna just sit back and “drive the car” like Herbert can and did this year…Baker gonna try some shyt and it‘ll blow up .


his mentality is good when its working,,,but he still has too many of those “wtf you doing bro” moments
 
  • Dap
Reactions: No1

King Poetic

Soul Rebel
Supporter
Joined
Feb 15, 2013
Messages
99,988
Reputation
20,143
Daps
486,790
Reppin
125th to Africa
Tough

But Baker

Baker off the fact he will run with the ball and try to get the first down for you

Both are kirk cousins turnover prone in key situations
 
Top