L.A Noire's missions were good but it was terrible every time you weren't in a mission.
Rage 2 was bad after you've seen and used all your abilities, it had nothing else to offer besides above average gunplay.
Mafia 3's gameplay loop was complete garbage water. The missions were fun tho.
Watch Dogs 1 speaks for itself.
Every PSP game I've played with an open world was terrible including the GTA games IMO.
I didn't care much for Scarface on PS2.
AC1 was good for it's time but playing it now will make you want to kill yourself.
That's all that comes to mind. Out of that list I think AC1 and Rage 2 were probably the worst I've played.