Randall Roberts of the
Los Angeles Times: 'How does it sound? On first listen, like a continuation of 'Voodoo,' a strange, surreal record that hits on mid-'70s Parliament and Funkadelic, Sly and the Family Stone's 'There's a Riot Goin' On,' the tripped-out oeuvre of Betty Davis and a dose of Band of Gypsies-era Jimi Hendrix. At times it chugs like slowed-down Bad Brains, coupling distorted guitar with a heavy rhythm section. Loose handclaps abound, adding a hefty dose of human soul rather than relying on synthetics."
David Greenwald of
The Oregonian: "These songs, recorded to analog tape, are as fearless and alive as a midnight jam session, the vivid production the opposite of a cut-and-paste studio Frankenstein project nipped, tucked and compressed into submission -- the kind of album we get too often from artists who must weigh audio volume and iPhone appeal against sounding like, well, artists. This is what happens when the drugs fade away, the money stops calling and the pressure lifts: on 'Black Messiah,' music's all that's left."
Miles Marshall Lewis of
Ebony: "Clearly a passion project for everyone involved, Black Messiah tosses commerciality to the wind and still wins on nearly every level. It might help if we could make out D'Angelo's lyrics more; there won't ever be much singing along here, no matter how many times you play it. But what were the odds that D'Angelo would return 15 years later with an album actually worth hearing?
Lauryn Hill, you're up."