A Song of Ice & Fire by George R.R. Martin: Book Discussion Thread

Mister Terrific

It’s in the name
Joined
May 24, 2022
Messages
5,335
Reputation
1,468
Daps
19,091
Reppin
Michigan
she keep giving rhaenyra bad advice and making her look stupid in front of the council

also she murdered like 1000 smallfolk last season and nobody calls her out for it. she's too damn smug. "the men are the bloodthirsty ones, we're levelheaded" bytch you're a mass murderer :mjlol:
Apparently it’s some chick named Sarah Hess that is making the nonsensical changes to the material
 

Warren Peace

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
4,265
Reputation
853
Daps
17,764
sorry for using this as the book spoilers house of the dragon thread (we did this in '22 im pretty sure)

but they bout to do my nikka so aegon dirty tonight :mjcry:
 

Chris Cool

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 22, 2014
Messages
30,971
Reputation
7,056
Daps
109,206
Reppin
So Cal
There's actually a spoiler thread.

We past 13 since the last book. Idk why nikkas still acting mad.
 

Warren Peace

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
4,265
Reputation
853
Daps
17,764
There's actually a spoiler thread.

We past 13 since the last book. Idk why nikkas still acting mad.
like for the books or just for the show? cuz sometimes nikkas think it's just for the show and stroll in thinking they're all caught up only to get hit by a book reader flinging actual spoilers out willy nilly
 

Chris Cool

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 22, 2014
Messages
30,971
Reputation
7,056
Daps
109,206
Reppin
So Cal
like for the books or just for the show? cuz sometimes nikkas think it's just for the show and stroll in thinking they're all caught up only to get hit by a book reader flinging actual spoilers out willy nilly
This is the book spoiler thread.

There's a show one. I haven't seen it bumped this season though.
 

Piff Perkins

Veteran
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
52,050
Reputation
18,972
Daps
283,683
Not exactly book related but I noticed the previous three eps of this season have had lower ratings than last season. Quite a bit lower. Could be due to the ridiculously long wait between S1 and S2 but I'm curious how HBO/Max views this. S3 has already been greenlit and there's talk of there being four total seasons. Not to mention the other spin off shows. If the ratings don't rebound I wonder if they reconsider the commitment to Martin's work.

Which gets me to the books...if this shyt dies out because of the shytty last two seasons of GoT plus people not really being into the repetitive nature of HOTD (it's basically two sets, King's Landing and Dragonstone, over and over) all while Martin fails to get a book out...what a fall from grace. I thought the disaster of the final season would compel him to get his version out ASAP. Now here we are halfway through the second season of a spin off show with no updates or hope for another book.

I like HOTD btw, a lot. But I def wonder if it's just too dreary with not enough likable characters. I'm baffled why they didn't just expand Cregan Stark's role this season to add a new setting to things. He'll be a massive character in later seasons anyway, why not just establish him now and give people some Stark shyt.
 

daemonova

hit it, & I didn't go Erykah Badu crazy, #yallmad
Joined
May 20, 2012
Messages
44,025
Reputation
3,530
Daps
72,589
Not exactly book related but I noticed the previous three eps of this season have had lower ratings than last season. Quite a bit lower. Could be due to the ridiculously long wait between S1 and S2 but I'm curious how HBO/Max views this. S3 has already been greenlit and there's talk of there being four total seasons. Not to mention the other spin off shows. If the ratings don't rebound I wonder if they reconsider the commitment to Martin's work.

Which gets me to the books...if this shyt dies out because of the shytty last two seasons of GoT plus people not really being into the repetitive nature of HOTD (it's basically two sets, King's Landing and Dragonstone, over and over) all while Martin fails to get a book out...what a fall from grace. I thought the disaster of the final season would compel him to get his version out ASAP. Now here we are halfway through the second season of a spin off show with no updates or hope for another book.

I like HOTD btw, a lot. But I def wonder if it's just too dreary with not enough likable characters. I'm baffled why they didn't just expand Cregan Stark's role this season to add a new setting to things. He'll be a massive character in later seasons anyway, why not just establish him now and give people some Stark shyt.
I think 4 seasons of Hotd is all you're getting so the rating dont matter as much.

Knight of the Seven Kingdoms is taking a novella a season (six episodes). That's stretching the material.

The first two (of three published books) takes place in one setting. But, for the most part, you'll finally get a sustained view from the small folk George R R martin always wanted.
 
Last edited:

jericho

The North Remembers
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
1,254
Reputation
260
Daps
4,671
Reppin
612
Zero update but since this thread has been upped cause of the show thought I'd post this GRRM blog from yesterday:


When WINDS OF WINTER is done, the word will not trickle out, there WILL be a big announcement… where and when I cannot say.

:mjlol: :snoop:

This blog post on Deadspin is almost a fukking decade old and has never been more true:


:pacspit:
 
Top