A Song of Ice & Fire by George R.R. Martin: Book Discussion Thread

[tjwettem]

I'm on on dance for my re read but stalled it to be closer to winds.
So I'm currently reading Dunk and Egg.

I did the exact same thing, saved the last 7 dance chapters and started on dunk and egg today

 

[O.Red]

Why you rereading before checking out Dunk and Egg

Those books are just as good and are relevent to the main series

Habit from comics

I rarely read side material but the way y'all talking about these books

 

[O.Red]

Btw I don't know if y'all discussing the show in here now so I'll post it in both

That scene where Davos confronts Melisandre about Shireen is the GOAT acting I've ever seen on that show

Davos had me bout to

And the slick commentary on religion

I even slick felt bad for Melisandre

 

[Piffery]

Btw I don't know if y'all discussing the show in here now so I'll post it in both

That scene where Davos confronts Melisandre about Shireen is the GOAT acting I've ever seen on that show

Davos had me bout to

And the slick commentary on religion

I even slick felt bad for Melisandre

Pretty sure a few Alfie Allen scenes have that beat

 

[O.Red]

Pretty sure a few Alfie Allen scenes have that beat

Nah breh

He's good but I've never felt a scene the way I felt that one

shyt had me

Davos cracking

And the silence was DEAFENING in that room

I've watched that scene at least 15x since last night

 

[detroitwalt]

Brehs, Winds of Winter IS DROPPING NOVEMBER 15TH!!!!!!!!


















Yes indeed, the critically acclaimed 10th episode of season 6 of HBO's hit tv series Game of Thrones, "The Winds of Winter" drops on Blu Ray on November 15th. Reserve your copy today.

That's neg-worthy breh

Pretty sure a few Alfie Allen scenes have that beat

Folks rave about Alfie Allen but none of his scenes have moved me like the Davos/Mel scene. Even on a 3rd or 4th rewatch that scene still hits me. Maybe it's cause I just don't care for Theon as a character.

 

[Jmare007]

Every time I see this thread up I get my hopes up that we are getting a date for WoW

 

[Piffery]

That's neg-worthy breh


Folks rave about Alfie Allen but none of his scenes have moved me like the Davos/Mel scene. Even on a 3rd or 4th rewatch that scene still hits me. Maybe it's cause I just don't care for Theon as a character.

Well show Theon was my favorite in the show since season 2 and book Theon is my favorite character in fiction since book 2 so maybe that's why
But as far as I can see he's given the best performance on the show consistently.
Was just watching the Rodrik execution scene the other day

 

[jericho]

How is Dunk and Egg?

I haven't read any of the side books

go out tonight and pick up those books/download em/whatever

All 3 are amazing. If I had to pick I'd go 1>3>2.... but that changes frequently.

 

[O.Red]

Am I the only one that thinks that Bran is actually Bran the builder? And possibly other chars throughout Westeros history?

@Adam3000 any insight on this?

I'm also thinking that maybe there's an ebb and flow of a Targ and a Stark being the 3ER

 

[T-K-G]

Am I the only one that thinks that Bran is actually Bran the builder? And possibly other chars throughout Westeros history?

@Adam3000 any insight on this?

I'm also thinking that maybe there's an ebb and flow of a Targ and a Stark being the 3ER

Now that we have an example of how he can effect the past it's definitely plausible, one of the most plausible theories left in the show atm.

 

[The Prince of All Saiyans]

Every time I see this thread up I get my hopes up that we are getting a date for WoW

at this point it's status

 

[Adam3000]

Am I the only one that thinks that Bran is actually Bran the builder? And possibly other chars throughout Westeros history?

@Adam3000 any insight on this?

Ehhh, that doesn't really make sense. He can't 'be' somebody when he isn't physically there

I suppose he could have influenced events that eventually led to the creating of all the "Bran" mythological characters, but I'm not sure that really makes sense either because why wouldn't the person whom he influenced be name on the myths?

My brain hurts too much thinking about it....and to be quite honest, I'm not sure I want to think too hard about it because we are never going to get a 7th book so we may never find out unless the show saves us or GRRM leaves behind detailed notes for publishing in his will

 

[Piffery]

Can't wait for Darkstar to steal Dawn

 

[Diunx]

fukk this thread