7/17 PBC on SHO: Jermell Charlo vs Brian Castaño (WBC/WBA/IBF/WBO Super Welterweight Titles)

Who Wins?


  • Total voters
    31
  • Poll closed .

R=G

Street Terrorist
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
123,265
Reputation
8,503
Daps
145,789
Reppin
Westcoast
117-111? Where did you see that? Castano threw and landed more punches. Charlo was only busy rounds 2, 10-12. If the scorecard was 114-113, I could accept that. There's no way that Charlo dominated by that many rounds.
It depends. Close rounds going one way can lead to a wild one sided scorecard.
 

Pimp

Banned
Joined
Sep 28, 2012
Messages
13,717
Reputation
-1,849
Daps
32,721
Reppin
NULL
I think round 10 should have been scored 10-8.. It was a one sided ass whooping. That gives charlo a majority decision.
 

patscorpio

It's a movement
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
120,650
Reputation
11,715
Daps
250,057
Reppin
MA/CT/Nigeria #byrdgang #RingGangRadio


E6jUUOxVoAM1_1t
 
Joined
May 15, 2012
Messages
28,010
Reputation
1,286
Daps
60,666
Reppin
NULL
Costano didn't do enough to win the belt, anybody got a problem with the draw is just charlo hater
73 percent thought Costano won that fight on the PBC poll, its just because they hate charlo

If this was 15 round Castano was not making it out on his feet, yet people think Charlo trying to duck the rematch already like he was the one breaking down at the end of the fight

Like I said, the end of the fight is the sign of the story, who see who was getting the worst of the wear the entire fight, it was castano because Charlo was stronger in the championship rounds and Castano was breaking down

Like I said their should be an immediate rematch, I'm sure nobody would mind seeing that again
 

theflyest

Veteran
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
26,786
Reputation
1,435
Daps
67,124
Reppin
NULL
I think he was a possible placement on the list but not a must have, you can argue other fighters being on there too. A nice run but mostly good but not great opponents and he lost to one of them once even if it was debatable. Bud had a similar run of good but not great opponents but he clearly dominated all of them, was never in a debatable fight, that's what translates to "eye test" factor and that's why he's a fix top 5.

Agreed

as I stated many times before, I don’t care for p4p list.

Jermell is accomplished, but based on the eye test, he simply isn’t as good as other guys on there.
 
Top