They REAAAAAAAALLY dropped the ball with that. Would have been a good way to explain Sweater Bray and the Fiend and his other personalities that are represented by the puppets. It makes sense that the Lake of Reincarnation would fukk him up because the whole Broken Universe is well.......Broken.
Thought that was obvious and a way for them to reboot wrestlers but maybe vince put an axe to it and said this has gone too damn far pals!