Devilinurear

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
26,562
Reputation
5,682
Daps
87,075
Reppin
NULL
"Wolvie was never lead man in the Xmen comics."

This means that he was not the top man, the numero uno wrt to his team mates in the X-men series.

That was Cyclops, Storm and then Nightcrawler. Wolverine was a massive character but not so massive that he was the main thrust of the X-Men comics.

In fact with the new (Uncanny) X-Men Jean and Scott were initially the two big ones. Then after Jean died and Scott left the focus was on Storm and Kitty and Wolvie.

Storm was the leader of the Xmen and the Morlocks.

I think you are getting lead confused with leader.
 

null

...
Joined
Nov 12, 2014
Messages
29,189
Reputation
4,881
Daps
46,387
Reppin
UK, DE, GY, DMV
I think you are getting lead confused with leader.

Ok but I am not. Jean Gray was also in my list right :youngsabo:. Angel too ..



I think you are confusing the comics with the movies.

Wolverine never was this "main man" in the X-men and especially not during the early days which the films are largely drawn from.

Wolverine was an anti-hero, the bruiser and an outsider (again) especially in the earlier comics.

Yes he was popular and that popularity as an anti-hero meant that he got his own mini-series but that was also a function of the times. Comic companies were just starting to commercially exploit mini-series, special editions and multiple x-teams.

This is the cover of the greatest X-men story to date and the end to a multi-year saga. No wolverine in sight.

covers-137-xmen-480x746.jpg


This is how the story climaxed. Scott and Jean given that extra respect as ORIGINAL X-men.

Meanwhile Wolverine was already removed from the battle and was off sleeping in a crater somewhere.

137_8_ScottAndJean.png


And even after Jean and Cyclops left Storm became the biggest narrative focus.

In fact over lets say the first 100 issues of the Uncanny X-men when did Wolverine take center-stage?

1. Wolverine Alone against the Hellfire Club - 1/2 issue.
2. Wolverine against Sabertooth with the Reavers - cross-over a few issues.
3. Wolverine against Sauron for 1.5 pages.
4. Wolverine being chased by Alpha-Flight for 2.x comics.
5. Wolverine against Wendigo - 1.5 issues.
6. Wolverine against the Brood - 1 issue.
7. Wolverine and Kitty in Japan - don't remember but only a few.
8. Old Wolverine in DOFP in the future.

That's the bulk of it. Jean and Scott had a 40 issue plus arc dedicated to them and even after Scott left they still couldn't leave him out. Then brought Madeleine Pryde in as Scott's replacement for Jean. Then they resurrected Jean. Then they gave us Rachel their daughter. Then their son.

When Magneto attacked around X-men 112 it was Cyclops who the story was told through.

When Magneto returned in X-men 150 it was Cyclops too who was the focus of that story.

Cyclops was the point man and our proxy for our insight into the villain. Storm is the one who (could have) almost killed him.

If it were the movies you could bet that this pivotal moments would have been given to wolvie. It was he after all who in the movies spoke to Magneto more than any other X-man and had more 1 on 1 fights with him. Not so in the comics!!

People who read those comics understand that Wolverine is important but we are tired of the reassessing of his relative place in the X-men based on what people have seen in the movies and/or in the cartoons.




I trust I don't have to list Jean's, Scott's and Storm's much longer story line list in detail.

:ufdup:Wolverine got outshone and eventually supplanted to some degree by Gambit and Bishop. No one ever replaced or supplanted Scott and Jean, because they are FAR more central to the entire X-men comic mythos.
 

Devilinurear

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
26,562
Reputation
5,682
Daps
87,075
Reppin
NULL
Ok but I am not. Jean Gray was also in my list right :youngsabo:. Angel too ..



I think you are confusing the comics with the movies.

Wolverine never was this "main man" in the X-men and especially not during the early days which the films are largely drawn from.

Wolverine was an anti-hero, the bruiser and an outsider (again) especially in the earlier comics.

Yes he was popular and that popularity as an anti-hero meant that he got his own mini-series but that was also a function of the times. Comic companies were just starting to commercially exploit mini-series, special editions and multiple x-teams.

This is the cover of the greatest X-men story to date and the end to a multi-year saga. No wolverine in sight.

covers-137-xmen-480x746.jpg


This is how the story climaxed. Scott and Jean given that extra respect as ORIGINAL X-men.

Meanwhile Wolverine was already removed from the battle and was off sleeping in a crater somewhere.

137_8_ScottAndJean.png


And even after Jean and Cyclops left Storm became the biggest narrative focus.

In fact over lets say the first 100 issues of the Uncanny X-men when did Wolverine take center-stage?

1. Wolverine Alone against the Hellfire Club - 1/2 issue.
2. Wolverine against Sabertooth with the Reavers - cross-over a few issues.
3. Wolverine against Sauron for 1.5 pages.
4. Wolverine being chased by Alpha-Flight for 2.x comics.
5. Wolverine against Wendigo - 1.5 issues.
6. Wolverine against the Brood - 1 issue.
7. Wolverine and Kitty in Japan - don't remember but only a few.
8. Old Wolverine in DOFP in the future.

That's the bulk of it. Jean and Scott had a 40 issue plus arc dedicated to them and even after Scott left they still couldn't leave him out. Then brought Madeleine Pryde in as Scott's replacement for Jean. Then they resurrected Jean. Then they gave us Rachel their daughter. Then their son.

When Magneto attacked around X-men 112 it was Cyclops who the story was told through.

When Magneto returned in X-men 150 it was Cyclops too who was the focus of that story.

Cyclops was the point man and our proxy for our insight into the villain. Storm is the one who (could have) almost killed him.

If it were the movies you could bet that this pivotal moments would have been given to wolvie. It was he after all who in the movies spoke to Magneto more than any other X-man and had more 1 on 1 fights with him. Not so in the comics!!

People who read those comics understand that Wolverine is important but we are tired of the reassessing of his relative place in the X-men based on what people have seen in the movies and/or in the cartoons.




I trust I don't have to list Jean's, Scott's and Storm's much longer story line list in detail.

:ufdup:Wolverine got outshone and eventually supplanted to some degree by Gambit and Bishop. No one ever replaced or supplanted Scott and Jean, because they are FAR more central to the entire X-men comic mythos.

You are trying to rewrite history. As his popularity grew wolverine would be the lead in stories same with any character who got a spike in popularity. Like I said he was the only one to have an ongoing title still going strong today. How is that Cyclops comic?
 

null

...
Joined
Nov 12, 2014
Messages
29,189
Reputation
4,881
Daps
46,387
Reppin
UK, DE, GY, DMV
You are trying to rewrite history. As his popularity grew wolverine would be the lead in stories same with any character who got a spike in popularity. Like I said he was the only one to have an ongoing title still going strong today. How is that Cyclops comic?

I gave you a list and you gave me truisms. What have I missed in my list? Or didn't you read them?
Give me a major X-men story arc focused on Wolverine that compares to the Jean+Scott one?

All the film stories are from that period.
 

Devilinurear

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
26,562
Reputation
5,682
Daps
87,075
Reppin
NULL
I gave you a list and you gave me truisms. What have I missed in my list? Or didn't you read them?
Give me a major X-men story arc focused on Wolverine that compares to the Jean+Scott one?

All the film stories are from that period.
This is your opinion

Days of the future past
 

filial_piety

Banned
Joined
Jun 21, 2012
Messages
11,107
Reputation
-2,760
Daps
27,456
Reppin
I95S
Just saw it....worst of the franchise imo. It felt very empty, and lacked a good back story. The lineup of X Men sucked, and they underplayed DP's powers.

Special effects were so so, and i hated how Nightcrawler and Beast looked like the same cheap make up as the Sonic the Hedge hog movie. The Nightcrawler back in the second movie looked better.

2 stars.
 

Norrin Radd

To me, my board!
Joined
Jun 9, 2013
Messages
48,127
Reputation
9,980
Daps
221,300
Reppin
Zenn-La
DARK PHOENIX Director Simon Kinberg Breaks Silence On Dismal BO Performance: "That's On Me"

After fairly horrendous reviews and an undeniably disappointing box office performance, Dark Phoenix can officially be labelled a bomb. In a rare move, the movie's director has now commented on the challenges he faced while helming Fox's final X-Men movie and taken full responsibility for its failings.

"It clearly is a movie that didn't connect with audiences that didn't see it, it didn't connect enough with audiences that did see it. So that's on me," Kinberg said during an interview with KCRW's The Business. However, the director did add that it wasn't painful for him to reflect on the film so soon after its poor opening weekend because he genuinely likes the movie. "I loved making the movie, and I loved the people I made the movie with," he said.

It recently came out that Kinberg stepped in to pick up the slack when Bryan Singer went AWOL while shooting previous installments Days of Future Past and Apocalypse, which is one of the reasons the studio and cast had confidence in him taking the helm of Dark Phoenix.

Now, Marvel Studios has control of the mutant heroes and will presumably reboot the X-Men at some point, integrating them into the MCU. Kinberg says he will miss working with the characters, but is looking forward to seeing what Marvel has in store for them.

"I love these characters. I love these world. I'll be super excited to see what Marvel does with them."

"My bad, guys" :russ:
 
Last edited:
Top