I just wan say, i been on a serious wu kick for a minute so ive been going over their catalog.
This album really got shyt on when it wasnt nearly as bad as I thought after all these years. While the lightness of the production took me out of the album, imo this album was just wutangs celebration on conquering the game. Its sound is almost like an outkast album. Which is NOT what wu fans want from wu but I understand why rza went this direction because it was the one part of the game he didnt conquer. Hes flirted with this beat style before, mostly in 2001 with bulletproof wallets, digital bullet and iron flag. But never taken it to this level.
I first started appreciating this album listening to the project strum remix version which made me appreciate it lyrically for what it is. The guys hadnt been so cohesive in a long time at this point. Cappadonna, Masta Killa Ugod GZA Meth and Rae all have serious verses on this album. Not that the other guys didny but i was suprised how much I loved their verses on the remix album. 8 diagrams def felt more hap hazard in its construction even if I feel today the original 8 Diagrams to be a 4.5 mic album and is probably my fav album of the late 2000s by a lot.
We should have known when wu massacre dropped and Our Dreams prod by rza was so clean and “pretty” sounding, where rza was gonna take this album. And honestly im not mad at it after all these years.
Best songs:
Imo, there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with the following tracks
Ruckus in B Minor 4.5/5
Crushed Egos 4.25/5
Pioneer The Frontier 4.25/5
Necklace 4/5
A Better Tomorrow II 5/5
Family Reunion 4/5
Already 1/2 of the album is dope. All these songs are FINE. ABT2 is the standout to me being a classic song imo. The rest are all bangers.
Issues tracks:
Miracle 4.25/5
also, in that class ; i to this day love miracle. The songbis representitive of godfather 3 style opera hit; hence the singing and mastakilla/rae verses. The synth clash at end with ghost dont even bother me. The beat is the best one theyve rocked on to this very day; I like this song and still find it fire. Hook got .75 took off bat. This would be a 5/5 wu song if they just got an old singer.
So thats 6/15
Keep watch: 3.75/5
the hook does not ruin the song. So many people cried about this song. At worst its a aversge joint and I quite like the beat and the verses. I think its a 3.5/5 joint at very least.
Preachers Daughter: 3.5/5
When i first heard this song I HATED IT. I havent listened to it in 10 years. I was suprised how much I enjoyed it. Again i relate this to outkast. This sounds like some idlewild shyt. Which makes me laugh cause i know if outkast rhymed on this same song everything the same people would go nuts over it but because its wutang it gets blown outta perportion. It sounds like wu having fun on it which I haveny personallu heard in years so it makes me laugh. I dont hate the track at all. Ghost actually kills it which struck me this time. Madta killa drops a childs play esque verse. I dont love it. Dont hate it but appreciate it now when I couldnt then. 3.5/5
9/15 tracks 3.5 or better off rip.
Following tracks I neither loved not hated and found them to be average. The strum remix of felt, 40th street black and mistaken identitu made me appreciate those songs more for what they are. I like those versions more than rzas but still rate most of these as average to good
Felt - 3.25/5 - i like the strum remix more but this version never bothered me.
40th street black - 3/5 - LOVE the strum remix but again this one dont bother me too much. What I dont like about it is weighed against what I do which is more than not.
Mistaken identity - 2.75 - i like the changeup over ugods part the best. Strum remix gives it edge it prolly needs. Dont hate it again its average at worst. Ive heard worst wu songs.
Hold the heater - 2.5/5 - beat isnt anything special. Guys just rhyming all over the place. Filler.
Ron oneil - 3/5 - one of the more maligned tracks. again i like more about it than I dont. Groove works more than some other tracks.
Never let go - 3.5/5 - i like this track, begining samplw is sick and the instrumentation is dope. Strum remix is dope cause he samples the sick intro to make a beat thats very wu but original is dope as well.
Final tally
Ruckus in B Minor 4.5
Felt 3.25
40th street black 3
Mistaken Identity 2.75
Hold the heater 2.5
Crushed egos 4.25
Keep watch 3.75
Miracle 4.25
Preachers daughter 3.5
Pioneer the frontier 4.25
Necklace 4
Ron oneil 3
A better tomorrow 5
Never let go 3.5
Wu tang reunion 4
Average: 55.5/75 = .74 = 3.7
Id give it 3.5 mics for sure just off beung 20 years 50+ albums in and dripping this. Maybe 3 mics with my stan glasses off. Its not any worse than 3 mics. Mostly songs lose while points for generic “modern” hooks.
And just for my ratings on wu album
36 - 5
Forever - 5
8 Diagrams (original) - 4.5
The W - 4
Iron Flag - 3.5
A better Tomorrow 3 - 3.5
Saga Continues 3.5
Also
Also, like I said I consider the 2010s to be like Wu’s celebration run. They have done a lot of tracks in this style since that really fill out the project. If anyone was interested in hearing the entirety of the sound; I reccomend these tracks as I play them with the album. Sorta like a 3 disk a better tomorrow / saga cintinues / of mics and men super albjm with my fav tracks from ir added with these.
Cappadonna - Cranberry
Masta Killa - All Natural
Wu-Tang - Savor WAVs
Wu-Tang - Of Mics and Men
Wu-Tang - Our Dreams
Wu-Tang - Wu Tang Reunion strum rmx
Wu-Tang - Felt strum rmx
Raekwon - a poems a hustle
YDB/Cappadonna - Legendary Love
Wu-Tang - Crack Babies 2.0 ft joe young
Wu-Tang - People Say
Wu-Tang - My Only One
Cappadonna/Masta Killa - Shorty
Wu-Tang - Gonna Love Me teyanataylor
Wu-Block - Driving Round
Ghostface - It may be glamor life
Masta killa - loyalty is royalty
Ugod - get mine
Gza - The Spark
Wu-Tang - Lesson Learned
Raekwon/Ghostface -Seen A Lot Of Things
Killah Priest - Color of Ideas
Method Man - Fly Navigation
Wu Tang - Wu-Tang Forever ft logic
Wu-Tang - Hood Go Bang remix
Wu-Tang - Unorthodox
Wu-Tang - Six Directions of boxing
The RZA - BEEZ ft kid cudi
Ugod - Epicenter ft rae deck scottywotty
Method man-Squad Up f streetlife havoc
Ghostface - Watch Em Holla ft wu
Raekwon - Butter Knives
Ugod - Fire ft method man scottywatty
Wu-tang - Crushed egos strum remix
Wu-tang - 40th st black strum remix
Inspectah Deck - The Eyes
Ghostface / killah priest - Starry Winters
Killa Sin - The Archer
Rae/Ghost - This is what it comes to rnx
Wu-Tang - if what they say is true
Wu-Tang - pearl harbor
Wu-Tang - rain on snow ft dj shadow
Wu-tang - piranhas ft forever mc
Method man - the oath
Meth/ghost - its that wu shyt
Ghostface - ghetto ft wu
Ghostface - purified thiught ft gza priest
Raekwon - wu crime ft gza priest
Ugod - heads up ft gza scotty watty
Ugod - skyscraper
Ghostface - murderspree ft wu