Would Peyton Manning winning a SB this year make him the GOAT without question?

[Snitchin Splatter]

It's time to start having that discussion.....
has any QB (not to mention one at his level) ever been put in a similar situation and performed like he has this year?

Could this be the greatest year a QB has ever had when taking in account outside circumstances?

 

[DStyles]

Elite Manning begs to differ.

And no, not to me at least.

 

[Jplaya2023]

I'LL up in a month whem the broncoes get knocked out.

threads like these dont end up well

 

[Kobe Bryant]

It's time to start having that discussion.....
has any QB (not to mention one at his level) ever been put in a similar situation and performed like he has this year?

Could this be the greatest year a QB has ever had when taking in account outside circumstances?

I could have told you he'd have a good time in Colorado.

 

[Mandizi]

He's top 5 ever regardless of how this season ends imo.

 

[MAKAVELI25]

5 super bowl appearances, 3 wins>>>

 

[yseJ]

 

[nomoreneveragain]

If they Colts beat the Saints he would have been GOAT

but winning with 2 different teams, would put him right up there

 

[Ineedmoney504]

he already the goat, atleast of this generation

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

I could have told you he'd have a good time in Colorado.

Shiiiit I already knew. I've been to Denver quite a few times one of the GOAT cities

 

[Jplaya2023]

5 super bowl appearances, 3 wins>>>

4 sb appearances, 4 wins, 3 mvps >>>>>> whatever the fukk u talking about

 

[Snitchin Splatter]

5 super bowl appearances, 3 wins>>>

Is this Terry Bradshaw you're talking about?

 

[Joe Sixpack]

It's time to start having that discussion.....
has any QB (not to mention one at his level) ever been put in a similar situation and performed like he has this year?

Could this be the greatest year a QB has ever had when taking in account outside circumstances?

No its not..

they said this shyt before the SB he lost against the Saints and I couldn't understand why.

Denver is not winning the SB..

 

[Dr. Fauci]

It's time to start having that discussion.....
has any QB (not to mention one at his level) ever been put in a similar situation and performed like he has this year?

Could this be the greatest year a QB has ever had when taking in account outside circumstances?

what hes doing with this team....its one of the greatest things I've ever seen in my lifetime on the football field


Some people will point out that the Broncos were in the playoffs and won a game last year, and thats very true. But, this guy has this offense going like no other. Hes turned Demarius Thomas into a top 5 WR in the game, he rarely ever throws a ball into bad coverage...and this guy is still gaining arm strength back as the season goes on. If he goes on to win the Superbowl...it would go down as one of the greatest NFL stories ever

 

[Brady-Carter]

Brady is chasing Joe the gawd.

Peyton is chasing his little brother...