Will CM Punk one day surpass the likes of a Y2J, Angle or HBK?

[InstantKlassik]

At least among internet/smark fans?

Do you think he's already eclipsed them?

Serious question, cause i lurked a a couple other wrestling forums out of curiosity of what those racists be talking about and a lot of them already got them in their top 5 of all-time Hell the majority of TSC praises him and The IWC in general holds Cm Punk in high regard, thoughts?

 

[KingDanz]

Not until he takes a shower, hit the weights & gets a clue..

 

[krackdagawd]

Surpass HBGOAT?

He could pass Y2J and Angle but I don't have him above those guys yet.

 

[SanfordMan75]

hell nah he is aight but will neva be like JeriGOAT,King Kurtis,& HBGOAT

 

[Ill Lou Malnati]

Surpass HBGOAT?

He could pass Y2J and Angle but I don't have him above those guys yet.

This.

 

[Brad Piff]

CM HEEEEL

 

[Mr. Negative]

nah. I been a CM Punk fan since.... well, for a while now.

He'll never be a better wrestler than Angle.

He'll never be as... look, man. Y2J came out and got not saying shyt, just smiling and leaving... for a brief moment he got that over.

The only 4 more complete wrestlers in HISTORY, IMO, than Y2J are Flair, Eddie Gurrero and HBK.

And out of that list, only Flair is a better Heel/Face/Tweener.

Y2J damn near the GOAT.

 

[Dog Based Gremlin]

Dude isnt even top 10 of all time maybe not even top 20 and in no particular order.....here are 20 superstars better than punk as a whole (not in ring)

1. Rock
2. Austin
3. HBK
4. HHH
5. Foley
6. Edge
7. Christian
8. Jeff Hardy
9. Macho Man
10. Goldberg
11. Lesnar
12. Rey
13. Eddie
14. Jericho
15. Raven
17. Kurt Angle
18. Sabu
19. RVD
20. Ric Flair

 

[InstantKlassik]

Surpass HBGOAT?

He could pass Y2J and Angle but I don't have him above those guys yet.

You saying he could pass King Kurtis but not HBK? shyt ain't adding up breh

 

[thevarangian]

In 20 years 20 year olds will be arguing in the internexus how CM Punk was a wrestler for real wrestling fans and Cena was a wrestler for little children.

 

[The Great One]

LMFAO. This is a joke/shock thread right?

 

[Ill Lou Malnati]

Dude isnt even top 10 of all time maybe not even top 20 and in no particular order.....here are 20 superstars better than punk as a whole (not in ring)

1. Rock
2. Austin
3. HBK
4. HHH
5. Foley
6. Edge
7. Christian
8. Jeff Hardy
9. Macho Man
10. Goldberg
11. Lesnar
12. Rey
13. Eddie
14. Jericho
15. Raven
17. Kurt Angle
18. Sabu
19. RVD
20. Ric Flair

 

[ECA]

I would say that he's already surpassed "King Kurt" in my book, and is well on his way in passing Y2GOAT imo.

But I'm in the minority that thought Kurt was a spot-monkey that had no idea how to tell a compelling story in the ring without being carried by Eddie, HBGOAT, Y2J, and ******

 

[Dog Based Gremlin]

1. The smarks were behind christian in 2005 massively. Had paul hryman bren around, he would have been just as big as Punk but instead they fired him and he went on to be the best WWE reject TNA ever had

2. Jeff Hardy made Punk what he is in WWE. Jeff gave hin credibility

3. Sabu and Raven are instant legends of extreme

 

[StatUS]

Punk is Top 3 in the business right now.

Bryan, Aries (don't watch TNA but I know he's gotta be killing it), and Punk. No Order.

You see that reaction he got when Jericho just mentioned his name? He's even better and more interesting now than the botched Reality Era.

He's built up a fan base that doesn't care if he's heel or face the wanna see what he does next.

Watch when he comes back. There's not as big of audience as when those 3 were at their height but I think the fanaticism is similar maybe even greater.