I've posted in this thread before so idk if I'm reiterating points I've already made...
BP1 is obviously a classic, but where I have problems is when I see rankings with it as the best album all time (da fukk?), or even as a top 15 album. It does NOT hold the same weight as classics that are pillars of the genre (36 Chambers, The Chronic, Doggystyle, OB4CL, etc.). It's a whole lower tier than those albums, b/c any one of those albums could be considered the #1 all time album.
BP1 is also not better than Reasonable Doubt...no fukking chance. The lyrics were dumbed down, and the flow more elementary on BP1. RD is easily a top 10-15 all time album. Also, I'll take Vol. 1 over BP1 any day. BP1 just too commercial and poppy.
BP1 also has some songs that are carried by production (Girls Girls Girls is fukking lame minus the beat, Hola Hovito), or songs that are just corny sounding now (H to the Izzo sounds like bubble gum pop). Jigga That nikka

Don't let nostalgia fool you into thinking these songs are still dope to this day.