Think about what you're insisting on though. Hollywood is so risk-adverse and bottom-line focused nowadays that 90% of films with any budget at all are either:
That's a great point and I'm not missing that.
My problem is how it is received by black audiences. It would be one thing if we received it with the caveat of "this is cool, now, but, we not tryna have every black character be the black version of a white character."
And I'm obviously not opposed to something like Chiraq being based on Greek tragedy.
I'm moreso taking the on the nose shyt "This is Commissioner Gordon...but black" as if it would be such a stretch to just make a new
Commissioner Johnson and making him someone who served under Gordon.
IMO, it signals a new way forward of not really making black character apart of the lore.
Don't make The Little Mermaid, Ariel, make her another mermaid from that world.
I get your reasons for saying that, but the way Hollywood works you're automatically making 90% of film material off-limits to Black actors and on-screen Black representation, because going original every time is NOT where the funding will go.
That's alarmist.
The reason I'm not holding my breath for African mythology movies is because even black people lack a grasp of it.
Economics aside, Hollywood is not doing a good job with black characters. What works for white women and LGTB doesn't work for us.
This is the Ronney Rule of movies. "Black representation" and two dollars can't get me a gallon of gas.
I don't worship at the alter of
"Black faces on movies/TV + mass audiences seeing them = better outcomes in life for black people."
Hell, I'm apart of group of people who wouldn't mind seeing
a black director/writing staff writing shyt about Queen Elizabeth or a reboot of Golden Girls (still with white women).
I'm basically directing my eyes to where the power is. Movie audiences will always be majority white. We're wasting time trying to force our way in their eye sight.
Racism is not going away.
None of those other names had their own movie, they're all sidekicks to the male characters with the starring roles. Ironman-Captain America-Hulk-Thor were the center of the universe, then Star-Lord, Ant-Man, Doctor Strange, Spiderman, Black Panther got their flicks. Captain Marvel was the first female lead in a film. I think even the lead villain was male in every one as well until Thor:Ragnarok.
You ever heard of the Bechdel test? "Does the movie at any point have two women who talk to each other about something other than a man?" Do you realize how rarely that test is fulfilled anywhere in the entire Marvel Universe? Diversity still pretty thin on that front.
Yes, a rule white women came up with based on their personal feelings towards what constituents importance in the piece of art. Don't get me started on white women being dishonest about their actual place in society and the white power structure. There are plenty of ways to measure good female characters other than "do they talk about men too much?" I'm sorry, I think that test is BS.
I'm sorry, I do not see the value in "diversity"--at least in the way the conversation is had amongst the circle who typically makes it
paramount.
So,
I can't enjoy a movie because it's got mostly white leads...but, my argument is for
more black leads in movies that are primarily watched by white people?
We want white people to want less of something that we want more of? It's such a circular argument.
This "own movie" stuff is pretty rudimentary thinking in way we try to have these convos about society.
The problem isn't lack of black men at the absolute top, it's that we can't even get in at fry cook, to work our way up to owner of the store.
You only have importance if your the lead? That is something you have to teach kids about and learn them out of. I don't agree with the "lead" argument.
"The internet" was trying to make the argument that the Marvel movies were sexist and racist before
Captain Marvel and
Black Panther came out.
Hell, T'Challa was a much better written character in a movie (
Civil War) he played like eight lead in rather his "own movie."
Back to the OP; my overall problem is, we're never gonna agree on this, but, to hell with this idea with
skipping the real world work of improving the lives of black people, "let's put them in movies."
Disclaimer: With this new crop of Marvel and DC movies, I hope they do with unpopular and unknown black characters just like they did Ant-Man
and Carol Danver
They really tried to tell us she was one of the most popular Marvel characters--as if her being a blonde, white , female, Superman wasn't why they put her on film.