I saw them both when I was just a kid 20+ years ago, so take my evaluation with a grain of salt but it got 7 daps.Strongly disagree with you on this one:
Predator 1 is one of the best alpha male movies in Hollywood. Everyone nailed their part. The movie stays mysterious for more than a half part, keeps raising the tension just perfect, has a very good pace, has one liners and other jokes timed really well. Keeps a great claustrophobic feeling throughout the movie, the jokes end as the movie progresses them knowing they are being hunted and they can't escape the jungles till they reach the helicopter. It also makes you care about every crew member just like Alien and Aliens films did. Predator 2? We only give a shyt about Glover.
And the battle duel between Arnold and Predator is epic with Arnold battle cry scene being the best scene from the franchise. shyt just got real.
Predator 2 meanwhile is all over the place, it tries to do too many unnecessary things, doesn't develop Predator storyline at all other than the ending where we find out more about the Predators. You're free to like any movie you want, just like any of us. But I've never heard anyone rating Predator 2 higher than the OG film. Can you imagine Alien movie based in the city? Oh wait they had one in AVP2, and that was one of the worst movies ever.
Predator 2 is like watching Alien 4, a cheapened out movie. You can enjoy it, Predator 2 did have some cool scenes, but in overall product it doesn't compare to the original one.
And I'm not the only one to have said it:
Top 10 Reasons “Predator 2” Is the Best of the “Predator” Franchise
8 Reasons Predator 2 Is the Best in the Series – Laser Time
Predator: 5 Ways Predator 2 Is The Definitive Sequel (& 5 Ways It's Predators)