This because at the end of the day gameplay replayability will always win over story replayability. Skyrim is one of the goats in terms of this. Witcher 3 has one of the story replayabilities. You can have 2 playthroughs where the decisions you make creates a lot of differences in the story minus the stuff that will always happen.I love both but it’s skyrim no question
I can replay Skyrim over and over. Witcher 3 is more one and done