Where yall got Arthur Morgan ranked all time?

[The G.O.D II]

He’s not even better than John Boring ass generic white protag

 

[Kairi Irving]

He’s not even better than John Boring ass generic white protag

John literally had no personality in the first game, Arthur exposed that lol

If we want to talk about boring generic protags, Joel is the epitome of that

 

[The G.O.D II]

John literally had no personality in the first game, Arthur exposed that lol

If we want to talk about boring generic protags, Joel is the epitome of that

I know your new gimmick is to shyt on all things TLOU but please stop it. John was interesting in the first or RDR1 due to the family dynamic and his deal with the feds. Arthur spent half of 2 being a bore/Dutch errand bytch before he randomly got AIDS. Nothing interesting about him. No backstory. No driving motive


Ezio Auditore
Marcus
Kratos
Nathan Drake
Master Chief
The half cac from second son
Joel
Geralt
Shepard
Max Payne

all better than bonanza cac Arthur

 

[Kairi Irving]

I know your new gimmick is to shyt on all things TLOU but please stop it. John was interesting in the first or RDR1 due to the family dynamic and his deal with the feds. Arthur spent half of 2 being a bore/Dutch errand bytch before he randomly got AIDS. Nothing interesting about him. No backstory. No driving motive


Ezio Auditore
Marcus
Kratos
Nathan Drake
Master Chief
The half cac from second son
Joel
Geralt
Shepard
Max Payne

all better than bonanza cac Arthur

I never had a gimmick. Joel and John in RDR1 were flat and boring.

 

[Kamikaze Revy]

Arthur was more of a father to Jack than John ever was...which by the way...they kind of hinted at the possibility of Arthur actually being Jack's biological father even though I would hope not since it would make him less "honorable".

 

[The G.O.D II]

I never had a gimmick. Joel and John in RDR1 were flat and boring.

Don’t think we haven’t seen you in the spoiler thread or you spoiling the end in a completely random thread cause someone shytted on GTA 6. What’s makes Arthur GOAT? 70% of the game is


Dutch: Arthur! I’ve got a plan. Take NPC to location and wait there. Trust me

Arthur: Yes sir Dutch

*on the way to mission*

NPC: I don’t know about Dutch. He’s changing

Arthur: Yea I kinda agree

Majority of time was being an errand boy and talking shyt behind his boss back

 

[kdslittlebro]

Arthur was more of a father to Jack than John ever was...which by the way...they kind of hinted at the possibility of Arthur actually being Jack's biological father even though I would hope not since it would make him less "honorable".

shyt Arthur was damn near a father to John by the end

 

[Wiles]

I thought John was better, but he's up there.

They are on the same level for me

ARTHUR MORGAN AS THE BIGGER BROTHER FOR JOHN FACTS

 

[Wiles]

Remember when everyone was like "who is this generic nikka? Bring back John!"

"i dont think this guy is gonna live up to the standard John set"

I was one of those people on YouTube

This

People hated until they played it for 5 min

 

[Kairi Irving]

Don’t think we haven’t seen you in the spoiler thread or you spoiling the end in a completely random thread cause someone shytted on GTA 6. What’s makes Arthur GOAT? 70% of the game is


Dutch: Arthur! I’ve got a plan. Take NPC to location and wait there. Trust me

Arthur: Yes sir Dutch

*on the way to mission*

NPC: I don’t know about Dutch. He’s changing

Arthur: Yea I kinda agree

Majority of time was being an errand boy and talking shyt behind his boss back

yeesh your a moron, i criticized GTA V and SA in the TLOU2 Spoiler thread fukking numbskull im least biased person in that thread, i happened to be shytting on it because tlou2 isnt good. The series itself is overrated.

 

[DPresidential]

Arthur Morgan
Marcus Fenix
John Marston
Tommy Vercetti
Solid Snake
Max Payne

 

[DPresidential]

He’s not even better than John Boring ass generic white protag

The fukk?

You didn't play the game at all.

 

[Kairi Irving]

Arthur Morgan
Link (controversial b/c he's a mute but this is my list so...)
Marcus Fenix
Tommy Vercetti
Solid Snake
Max Payne
Leon Kennedy

Arthur
Tommy Vercetti
John Marston
My favorites of all time. Fighting games characters wouldn't be fair as they arent focused on character development, just design, so my list are these three.

 

[Kairi Irving]

The fukk?

You didn't play the game at all.

Hes being spiteful because of tlou2 criticism. The cycle of hate

 

[DPresidential]

Arthur
Tommy Vercetti
John Marston
My favorites of all time. Fighting games characters wouldn't be fair as they arent focused on character development, just design, so my list are these three.

I actually changed my list a bit.
I had to take Link out. It just wouldn't be right in this group. But, I agree with you