If you freely admit that these are just "what if's" on your part, why are you getting bent out of shape when they are rightly labeled speculation?
spec·u·la·tion
ˌspekyəˈlāSH(ə)n/
noun
- 1.
the forming of a theory or conjecture without firm evidence.
Again, let's forget about Egypt for a second, this kind of thinking is exactly the reason why this smart-dumb method of analyzing history will always be an academic dead end in general, and a roadblock for those people who want to study real history and may not know where to start.
Because you both are completely ignoring things I'm using to help prove my point. Be fair, but y'all aren't doing that. Now you come with some "academia" nonsense, when i already stated all I want is people to come back with some creative ideas on what could have happened, but again y'all keep ignoring that part. I think you are one of those "I read a million books the last 50 years, I have all the answer", but can't put two, and two together. Maybe creative thinking is hard for you, and this is why you are missing some of the things I'm implying. I'm not dissing you, but I notice you do this a lot.
And you have no clue what you're talking about, this is exactly how people in academia discover things, they do roundtable discussions, and throw out ideas. Then they come up with a REASONABLE conclusion. Then they go see if it can be validated. It seems to me, yall don't want to think, and get offended when someone else questions the status quo. I have yet to see you come with something creative as to what happened in the past. You just put down others, who do it, and repeat what you read.
You keep saying you are repeating facts, but I just gave evidence some of your "facts" arent facts anymore. That's why I keep writing ALL OF THIS IS THEORY. Evidence is always popping up that debunks what we once thought. Even the scientists who I linked admitted they have to rethink what they thought about Egypt, but you two won't. This is just Egypt, imagine what other stuff is wrong, that y'all swear are concrete facts.
This is AT LEAST the third time I wrote this, but you say "if i freely admit these are what ifs, why am I getting bent out of shape". This tells me y'all are just hard headed, and like to argue, just to be right. shyt is sad.