When Sonny got killed, what do you think the LIVE theater reaction was like?

Joined
Jan 19, 2017
Messages
35,369
Reputation
-398
Daps
86,642
you couldnt be more wrong breh

gangster movies have always been popular. you can go back and watch scarface and the public enemy from the 30s if you want. spoiler alert: the main characters were reckless hotheads and they died at the end

The genre itself is indeed old as Hollywood but clearly the manner in which TGF was approached compared to its predecessors was different but I do agree the hot headed one is in the crosshairs. Maybe I should have said it redefined the genre

I still argue that the manner in which Sonny was killed was unexpected. You were prepped for a showdown between him & Carlo which never came. That was shocking
 

Baka's Weird Case

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jul 25, 2015
Messages
16,013
Reputation
7,102
Daps
78,431
Reppin
Goon Squad - Catset
The genre itself is indeed old as Hollywood but clearly the manner in which TGF was approached compared to its predecessors was different but I do agree the hot headed one is in the crosshairs. Maybe I should have said it redefined the genre

I still argue that the manner in which Sonny was killed was unexpected. You were prepped for a showdown between him & Carlo which never came. That was shocking
oh gangster movies for sure went in a different direction after the godfather. they reinvented the wheel.

by the time i actually saw the movie id already seen sonnys death parodied on the simpsons and i knew it was coming so maybe it would have been more shocking in real time in 72
 

obarth

R.I.P Char
Poster of the Year
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
16,852
Reputation
9,196
Daps
83,863
Reppin
Pawgs with dragons
I think Sonny's eventual violent death was predictable from a mere literary standpoint. You can go back to works of Shakespeare and see it in play (pun not intended), i.e Mercutio in Romeo and Juliet. That hot headed, temperamental character who may have motives deemed "honorable" or "just" by the audience, but is fated for a tragic end. That said, I think it was probably shocking to the original viewers of the film for reasons already stated.
 

obarth

R.I.P Char
Poster of the Year
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
16,852
Reputation
9,196
Daps
83,863
Reppin
Pawgs with dragons

Marlon Brando is a huge reason I can't fukk with certain actors nowadays that try to attempt the silent approach to acting. These new cats can't convey a multitude of emotions with little to no words like this, and instead come off as talentless/limited, whether that's the case or not.
 

x-factor7

Superstar
Joined
May 22, 2012
Messages
3,760
Reputation
854
Daps
14,837
Reppin
Detroit
I'll bet they were pretty shocked, unless they saw Bonnie and Clyde and that ending, which I believe was an influence to that scene.
 

jackswstd

Retired
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
72,976
Reputation
8,927
Daps
265,112
Reppin
Chicago
I’m sure there were gasps and probably some people that looked away or cried. That was a brutal scene. First time I saw The Godfather I was :damn: Brando at the funeral home was an incredible piece of acting, you felt Vito’s pain looking at his first born lying on a cold slab.
 

KalKal

Superstar
Joined
Aug 23, 2014
Messages
5,987
Reputation
1,085
Daps
16,150
Reppin
No Whammies!!
I bet they were like
russell.gif


Because it was clear as day that it would happen.



This is pretty much it, he was a clearly fundamentally flawed character that clearly couldn't run the business, and he ended up being the exact opposite of what Michael eventually became later on in the film.

It's predictable that he would die, but how is it predictable that he would die right then and there? How would the original audience have any clue that the hit men would know exactly when and where he would show up, if we just saw him spontaneously jump into a car in anger? (Unless they were already spoiled by reading the novel?) There's not much on screen that would tip viewers off that it would happen BEFORE he got to his sister's.

This thread actually inspired to rewatch the whole movie between yesterday and today for the first time in decades. The scene is still shocking, even though its the specific scene I was looking for.

It's kind of an overly complicated setup for a murder, actually. Relying on a character not "in" on the murder to call the victim at that exact moment, and for him to drive that exact route, and for no other car to be in between his car and the hitman's car at the toll booth.
 

Jimmy the gent

I'm still eatin off Lufthansa
Joined
Mar 28, 2014
Messages
1,134
Reputation
1,170
Daps
1,873
Reppin
North Side Perth
Most powerful crime family in the flick? Clear as day? Nah...he was coming out with 8 bodyguards everywhere..sent like a 100 men to the hospital after the incident with the Police Captain.
Yeah, 100 button men on the street 24 hours a day still waiting for Sollozzo to show one hair on his ass:youngsabo:
 

FaTaL

Veteran
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
103,213
Reputation
5,105
Daps
206,073
Reppin
NULL
Kicking a guy after shooting him hundreds of times, it’s not like he’s going to feel it

:manny:
 
Top