What makes Illmatic that great?

Yagirlcheatinonus

Icon Poster
Bushed
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
10,264
Reputation
-200
Daps
16,791
Reppin
NULL
In my opinion those albums where less versatile as far as subject matter goes. And ready to die came out after illmatic and shows some influence from it.

Chronic and Doggystyle set the stage for hip hop in the 90s because it had catered to each crowd. Ready 2 Die influence came from The Chronic like Diddy said. And don't say nothing about the album covers. Nas was a kid on his cover and BIG was a baby. Illmatic didn't Influence RTD like that.
 
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
3,023
Reputation
70
Daps
1,577
Reppin
401 Prov City
Chronic and Doggystyle set the stage for hip hop in the 90s because it had catered to each crowd. Ready 2 Die influence came from The Chronic like Diddy said. And don't say nothing about the album covers. Nas was a kid on his cover and BIG was a baby. Illmatic didn't Influence RTD like that.

Doggystyle and Chronic mightve set the stage for west coast hip hop in the 90s... but im pretty sure the G Raps and Rakims from the late 80s set the stage for 90s east coast boom bap
 

Alexander Wiggin

All Star
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
3,434
Reputation
1,352
Daps
10,498
Reppin
Paris Saint-Germain
For me Illmatic's greatness goes beyond its technical flawlessness. Illmatic is greater than the sum of its parts. If you think of it just in terms of hot beats and hot lyrics then yes, I suppose it can be matched by a few other albums. But what sets it apart in my eyes is just the....I don't know, the mood it creates when you're listening to it. It's what sets it apart from IWW, who was technically perhaps even better than Illmatic. But Illmatic has that X factor about it. It goes beyond just entertainment.

The core purpose of art is to sensitize, to provoke thought and emotion. And no album does that as good or better than Illmatic. Illmatic is the only album I’d praise for reaching the artistic and philosophic heights of literature.

The dude Nas caught lightning in a bottle with Illmatic. I don't think what he did will ever be achieved again.

Yeah, I'm a stan. What? :pacspit:

exactly, it's hard to put words on it, but it's like what pete rock was saying on the illmatic footage, "i can't even explain"
 

Yagirlcheatinonus

Icon Poster
Bushed
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
10,264
Reputation
-200
Daps
16,791
Reppin
NULL
Doggystyle and Chronic mightve set the stage for west coast hip hop in the 90s... but im pretty sure the G Raps and Rakims from the late 80s set the stage for 90s east coast boom bap

All 90s east coast wasn't boom bap. And when I say set the stage for hip hop I mean structure of albums. After Doggestyle and Chronic dropped you knew you had to appeal to more than one demographic if you were going to sell records, which is why Nas didn't go plat until his second album. Illmatic appealed to hip hop purist and fans of lyrics which is cool. But it wasn't accepted on all markets. Snoop came out and broke sells records. Chronic and Doggystyle were blueprint albums for a rapper to obtain success in the
90s.
 

MeachTheMonster

YourFriendlyHoodMonster
Joined
May 24, 2012
Messages
69,418
Reputation
3,794
Daps
109,344
Reppin
Tha Land
Chronic and Doggystyle set the stage for hip hop in the 90s because it had catered to each crowd. Ready 2 Die influence came from The Chronic like Diddy said. And don't say nothing about the album covers. Nas was a kid on his cover and BIG was a baby. Illmatic didn't Influence RTD like that.

Both nas and big admitted to borrowing from each other, illmatic came first so :yeshrug: in my opinion both the chronic and doggystlye where very limited in their appeal and subject matter. Illmatic appealed to fans of both of those albums and the fans of RTD.
 

ZEB WALTON

ayo! - BEZ
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
10,946
Reputation
985
Daps
18,923
Reppin
No Father To MY Style.. A Son Unique
i feel bad for younger fans who cannot discern difference between the albums from back in the late 80s-90s because of the over saturation/change in the market.

because its one of a kind. no matter how many times a rapper trys to remake it
 

the rhyme king

truth.com
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
7,235
Reputation
-1,680
Daps
3,038
Reppin
i refuse to conform
This rhythmatic explosion, is what your frame of mind has chosen
I'll leave your brain stimulated, nikkaz is frozen
Speak with criminal slang, begin like a violin
End like Leviathan, it's deep well let me try again
Wisdom be leakin out my grapefruit troop
I dominate break loops, givin mics men-e-straul cycles
Street's disciple, I rock beats that's mega trifle
And groovy but smoother than moves by Villanova
You're still a soldier, I'm like Sly Stone in Cobra
Packin like a rasta in the weed spot
Vocals'll squeeze glocks, MC's eavesdrop
Though they need not to sneak
My poetry's deep, I never fell
Nas's raps should be locked in a cell
It ain't hard to tell

his rhyme schemes were more advanced then anybody else at the time
 

JoelB

All Praise To TMH
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
23,315
Reputation
4,200
Daps
83,946
Reppin
PHI 2 ATL
That album will forever be the benchmark EVERY other album will be compared to for the rest of time.

In order for you to claim that an album is G.O.A.T u must first make an argument for why its better than Illmatic....


















18 years Later and nobody has done it yet....except for certain people who prefer IWW over it ....either way Nas wins and Life Is Good :youngsabo:
 

AkaDemiK

I Love Hip-Hop
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
42,179
Reputation
6,160
Daps
106,157
because that album is the definition of perfect

perfect flow
perfect cover
perfect voice
perfect style
perfect casting of producers
perfect beats
perfect lyrics (not one single word off beat on 9 songs whether he accelarate or rap slow, thats pretty impressive)
perfect order of track
perfect balance between street talk and spiritualism, negativity and optimism
perfect time to be made and drop
perfect legacy (in terms of ny and qb scene)
perfect label record
perfect lenght (debatable but to me his shortness is a strengh)
perfect replay value
perfect features (az, q tip, wiz and pete rock's choruses, olu dara trumpet)
perfect scratch samples (rakim, craig g, biz, t la rock)
perfect intro
perfect videos
 

blazn101

TPC life..
Supporter
Joined
Jun 7, 2012
Messages
3,158
Reputation
3,371
Daps
8,947
Reppin
Midwest
Fo me, what makes illmatic great, and i like IWW more, but what Nas did with illmatic is he made me feel like i was in NYC. The sounds, the flow, takes you there
Not many Hip hop records did that. I can put that album on now and it takes me to 90's
like i'm really there. It was a complete body of work, and it showed me that a rapper could be an artist. The way he painted his pictures with his words with thoses beats...
 

JulesWinfield

TheBrehdrenMovement
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
7,723
Reputation
1,060
Daps
10,116
The masterful lyrics and production.

:ahh:

:lolbron: this. nas struck gold on every verse and q-tip, premier, pete rock, extra p, les hooked him up nice with production. if someone doesn't understand what makes illmatic great it's their problem :manny: even the genesis is classic.
 

CaughtInTWebb

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
6,974
Reputation
944
Daps
12,183
Reppin
Big D, Texas
I came in here ready to say it's not that great until I realized how much I play the hell out of this album and it's amazing......plus dude was a damn teenager when he dropped this....a TEENAGER.
 
Top