What film seems like it doesn’t belong in a certain director’s filmography?

[semicko82]

Example
Wes Craven- Music of My Heart
Steven Spielberg- The Color Purple

 

[Bob Loblaw]

Ridley Scott - American gangster

 

[semicko82]

David Fincher-Alien 3
Martin Scorsese Hugo

 

[valet]

Spike lee- inside man

 

[semicko82]

Spike lee- inside man

Good one, What about 25th Hour?

 

[semicko82]

Robert Altman Popeye

 

[valet]

Good one, What about 25th Hour?

Yep

 

[SNYC]

Red Tails - George Lucas. I could see Spielberg making it though

 

[semicko82]

Red Tails - George Lucas. I could see Spielberg making it though

George Lucas didn’t direct Red Tails

 

[SNYC]

George Lucas didn’t direct Red Tails

Yeah i know. He only did the extra footage/reshoots.

But that whole project was HIM. He claimed that was his 'passion project'

The HBO version was better

 

[OmegaK2099]

Elvis - john carpenter

 

[jackswstd]

Robert Rodriguez- The Faculty

 

[semicko82]

Elvis - john carpenter

 

[BrownBunny]

Example
Wes Craven- Music of My Heart
Steven Spielberg- The Color Purple

Spielberg has several genres in his filmography and he did The Color Purple to establish himself as a director capable of doing serious work. Why shouldn’t it be in his filmography?

 

[semicko82]

Spielberg has several genres in his filmography and he did The Color Purple to establish himself as a director capable of doing serious work. Why shouldn’t it be in his filmography?

I know that, but that type of movie was anomaly for him compared to ET and the Indiana Jones movies