Bringing this thread back to life lmao!
Warren Moon would throw for 6,000 yards in today's game.
Randall would be like Mahomes but more athletic and not quite as much of a passing magician.
Vick would be a better version of Lamar
McNabb would be Dak (when Dak is having a good day). Big, durable guys that can torch a defense but will also miss some random throws.
McNair....not sure there's a good comp for him. Something like Dak physically but more like Aaron Rodgers + Russell Wilson combo. Dude would have none of the injuries he used to play with. Y'all remember the pre-game show back in the day. "Steve McNair - a ruptured spleen, two broken legs, a broken arm and a cracked spine......he will be active for today's game
" Breh shoulda had a 99 or 100 Toughness rating in Madden. That dude would have been a heavyweight champ if he'd been born 30 to 40 years earlier than he was.
Jeff Blake/Kordell Stewart/Tony Banks/Aaron Brooks/Anthony Wright etc., not sure. Probably great back-ups to decent starters depending on the situation they're in.