Obreh Winfrey

Truly Brehthtaking
Supporter
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
20,852
Reputation
25,492
Daps
131,964
I know it's an alternative time line, but is it any good? Emiya da Gawd isn't in it is he?
Ehh it's ok. I always liked the concept of the Fate series, but they kinda jumped the shark with this one, doing some gender swaps they didn't need to and over sexualizing the heros. I'm not a fan of fan service, so that rubbed me the wrong way. Most of the action is pretty legit though. I liked the art and the soundtrack enough that I went out and downloaded it. The interpretation of Emiya in this one is interesting :ehh:
 

Neuromancer

Rouge AI
Supporter
Joined
Oct 16, 2015
Messages
79,559
Reputation
15,692
Daps
192,352
Reppin
A Villa Straylight.
Ehh it's ok. I always liked the concept of the Fate series, but they kinda jumped the shark with this one, doing some gender swaps they didn't need to and over sexualizing the heros. I'm not a fan of fan service, so that rubbed me the wrong way. Most of the action is pretty legit though. I liked the art and the soundtrack enough that I went out and downloaded it. The interpretation of Emiya in this one is interesting :ehh:
I see. I'll check it I guess. Fate was originally an eroge so I can see why they would lean on fanservice.
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
45,987
Reputation
3,894
Daps
69,591
Reppin
Michigan
Just finished the Dungeon Exploration Arc of Black Clover. Not bad at all. If the show can really build on this I'll concede it's a bit better than the average shonen.
 

staticshock

Veteran
Joined
Apr 15, 2017
Messages
38,942
Reputation
5,435
Daps
165,816
Reppin
Atlanta


they really do have an anime for everything :ohhh:

the musician and band director in me wants to watch this entire series in 1 day. anyone know where I can find it?
 

LordDeathwatch

Valar Morghulis
Supporter
Joined
Feb 10, 2017
Messages
14,837
Reputation
12,509
Daps
73,826
Reppin
Baltimore, MD / Charlotte, NC
*Overlooks all Black Clover slander*

Anyone watching Fate/Grand Order or Fate/Apocrapha?

Apocrypha is definitely worth a watch, takes an interesting angle on the entire Holy Grail War while managing to unearth some Legends you don't expect to amount to shyt but end up being pretty boss.

I was pleasantly surprised. :ehh:
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
45,987
Reputation
3,894
Daps
69,591
Reppin
Michigan
*Overlooks all Black Clover slander*
Problem is the fans of the show are trying to put this on the Shounen Mt. Rushmore.

It's more favorable comparison is something like Fairy Tail. To me that's not an insult because I like Fairy Tail but it should never be compared to greatness. Fairy Tail has a lane somewhere in the middle of the pack and as long as you accept that you can watch it and enjoy it but once you start looking for greatness you're gonna be disappointed. Almost any good idea the show has originated and was better executed elsewhere.

There's plenty of series I like that I also know are ok at best shows. There are other shows I like but also recognize that they're among the best shows ever made.

I didn't even start enjoying Black Clover until I quit trying to see a GOAT status show and just accepted it as a more typical generic Shonen and moved on.
 

twan83

GOAT FATHER
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
27,195
Reputation
7,121
Daps
55,702
Reppin
Texas
Problem is the fans of the show are trying to put this on the Shounen Mt. Rushmore.

It's more favorable comparison is something like Fairy Tail. To me that's not an insult because I like Fairy Tail but it should never be compared to greatness. Fairy Tail has a lane somewhere in the middle of the pack and as long as you accept that you can watch it and enjoy it but once you start looking for greatness you're gonna be disappointed. Almost any good idea the show has originated and was better executed elsewhere.

There's plenty of series I like that I also know are ok at best shows. There are other shows I like but also recognize that they're among the best shows ever made.

I didn't even start enjoying Black Clover until I quit trying to see a GOAT status show and just accepted it as a more typical generic Shonen and moved on.

Goat shows are a matter of personal opinion having said that consensus can have a say so too
 

Mr. Jack Napier

#MambaForever
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
43,088
Reputation
6,910
Daps
157,542
Reppin
The Empire State
Problem is the fans of the show are trying to put this on the Shounen Mt. Rushmore.

It's more favorable comparison is something like Fairy Tail. To me that's not an insult because I like Fairy Tail but it should never be compared to greatness. Fairy Tail has a lane somewhere in the middle of the pack and as long as you accept that you can watch it and enjoy it but once you start looking for greatness you're gonna be disappointed. Almost any good idea the show has originated and was better executed elsewhere.

There's plenty of series I like that I also know are ok at best shows. There are other shows I like but also recognize that they're among the best shows ever made.

I didn't even start enjoying Black Clover until I quit trying to see a GOAT status show and just accepted it as a more typical generic Shonen and moved on.

I really like Fairy Tail, but BC is better
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
45,987
Reputation
3,894
Daps
69,591
Reppin
Michigan

Code Geass was made by Gorou Taniguchi and Ichiro Okouchi. Clamp did the character designs. Saying the series is created by women is disingenuous. If two guys craft a series and get woman to draw the artwork for them does that make the women the creator or them?

If you look at CLAMP's artwork and Code Geass the character designs are similar.
 
Top