Went to see "The Hate U Give"...she got a White boy!

Laidbackman

All Star
Joined
Jul 9, 2017
Messages
5,091
Reputation
391
Daps
8,093
Reppin
ATL, but rasied in DMV
Breh, the movie only came out last year or something. :heh:

I haven't even seen the movie, only just now read the book. Read it to see whether or not it was the sort of thing I should recommend to kids, then came on here to see what the takes were.
if you're a Black man in this day, you should be reading something much better.
 

Professor Emeritus

Veteran
Poster of the Year
Supporter
Joined
Jan 5, 2015
Messages
50,906
Reputation
19,616
Daps
202,583
Reppin
the ether
if you're a Black man in this day, you should be reading something much better.
I ain't recommending this shyt to men, I'm thinking about whether I'd recommend it to kids.

That being said, if you got other suggestions for youth lit I'm definitely all ears. :ehh:
 

Laidbackman

All Star
Joined
Jul 9, 2017
Messages
5,091
Reputation
391
Daps
8,093
Reppin
ATL, but rasied in DMV
I ain't recommending this shyt to men, I'm thinking about whether I'd recommend it to kids.

That being said, if you got other suggestions for youth lit I'm definitely all ears. :ehh:
This book sure wouldn't be one of them, unless you want to get little Black girls checking for White boys early. Or unless you want to entertain Black youth with what they already know as well, after what happened to Tamir Rice. I don't know why this is so hard for you to understand. Are you a brother? Are you even Black? Or you just like cream with your coffee.
 

FunkDoc1112

Heavily Armed
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
19,141
Reputation
5,713
Daps
99,849
Reppin
The 718
In the book there's only one Black guy in her grade, and they overtly have the fight the stereotype all the White kids put on them that they should get together just because they're the only two Black kids in their class.




He wasn't a Black Panther, he was a former gangbanger who just stanned the Black Panthers (at least in the book). In the book he had to get her out of the hood because it was too dangerous for her to be there as his daughter was always going to be a target and the local school wasn't shyt for kids and just kept them in the gang, but he was trying to be the ultra-overprotective father who would keep her from dating at all, and he didn't even know about the White boy until way late.




That was a stupid change from the book, because in the book he never touches the hairbrush, he just begins to open the door and the cop claims after-the-fact that the hairbrush looked like a gun handle when it was just sitting inside the car door. I guess they had him grab it in the movie cause the explanation took too long for film.




Cop don't look innocent in the book AT ALL. He's pure guilty from beginning to end with no excuses.




That scene ain't even in the book at all.




None of that stuff he was talking about was in the book at all.




In the book that happens near the end but it is almost like an aside. The kingpin getting locked up is like a silver lining but the police violence is still the central cloud and it's responding to that violence that she's focused on all the way down to the final lines. It does not feel like a "rosy" ending at all, but she's empowered because she's going to keep speaking up against those cops.


I had some problems with the book, but it sounds like the problems people having with the movie are completely different.
The movie doesn't stray too far from the book aside from the scenes you mentioned...the Coli's reaction to the movie is because as soon as they saw her with a white boy they started seeing red :heh:
 
Top