Ionno if I can say that ASM 1 & 2 were the best...but I do think they were unfairly hated on, especially 2, despite me not liking Jamie's Electro all like that. Wasn't a fan of Dehaan's Green Goblin either. Also didn't like mechanical Rhino, nor his underutilization.
All three Spidermen actors have been good so by default Garfield gets no advantage in comparison.
Lizard sucked and Goblin/Electro sucked.
Ock was amazing and had amazing fight scenes. Same to Mysterio.
Garfield had a good suit but so have the other two.
Basically he’s her worst of a good bunch
Deal
Nah, Tobey wasn't good so much as everyone just was loving the fact that a Spiderman movie was actually made. He barely ever made quips as Spiderman and looked very pathetic as Peter Parker. I know that's kinda how the character was back in the 60's, but still, looking back, it's harder to watch now than it was then.
Andrew was a very solid Spiderman, but just a lil off as Peter, which may have also not been his fault as much as how he was written in that time.
Holland's the best all around Peter/Spiderman combo as a character, outside of the excessive Tony influence, which isn't any fault of him.