We're not talking that about the people who have zero interest in Sifu though. Those people were never going to buy it. We're talking about capturing every possible sale.
I'm willing to bet that 90% of the people who are interested in Sifu are also interested in either Horizon or Elden Ring, and if they are frugal, they'll likely take the bigger and more robust game. It WILL affect sales. Plus you gotta think about how games are marketed now, you think streamers are going to stream Sifu over Elden Ring? Who the fukk is going to play Saints Row over Horizon? Both games cost $70.
Those destiny, horizon, Elden ring, saints row, maybe even dying light 2 (comes out a little earlier) cast a wide net. Most people buying anyone of those games probably just aren’t gonna buy more tha one game in that time period.
There’s also the marketing blitz that horizon forbidden west and Elden ring will cause. Whether its controversy, accolades, previews, reviews, whatever. Sifu will release while people are in the middle of playing Horizon while Destiny and Elden Ring are dropping reviews
Sifu is a game that needed a good week to itself like Kena got.
Again, this assumes that all of these people were going to be interested in all of these games just by default, and are all of the same quality.
For example, Saints Row: that shyt flopping will have absolutely nothing to do with when it releases, and more to do with the fact that it started with a pretty negative reaction, and they don't seem to be in much of a rush to fix that.
Or, anecdotally, I couldn't care less about Horizon, Elden Ring, or Dying Light 2. I'm getting in on Witch Queen, Sifu, and maybe Saints Row if it somehow presents something of value.
Either way, the variety is enough for all to be some form of successful, I think. It's the first big release window following the holidays, which aren't giving players who don't want a shooter or racing game something big to pick up. That should work just fine for the people that have been waiting.