If you go back,
The Tigers drafted Justin Verlander.
They drafted Rick Porcello, who never really learned how to control his powerful arm. By the way, Porcello was traded to the Mets for Yoenis Cespedes. Cespedes was then moved to the Mets for Michael Fullmer and Luis Cessa. People thought Fullmer was going to be a front-end starter. It just didn't pan out.
They drafted Nick Castellanos who has been a valuable bat for the Cubs and Reds (not so much with the Phillies so far).
They had a horrible stretch of 1st round draft picks from 2013-2018 where they took Corey Knebel, Jonathan Crawford, Derek Hill, Cristin Stewart, Beau Burrows, Matt Manning, Alex Faedo and Casey Mize. Ugh.
The way the Tigers wound up with Max Scherzer was through a 3-team trade with the Yankees and Diamondbacks.
New York received Curtis Granderson.
Arizona received Edwin Jackson and Ian Kennedy.
Detroit received Max Scherzer, Phil Coke, Daniel Schlereth, and Austin Jackson.
While Granderson had some good years in New York, Detroit won this trade easily by getting a 25 year old Max Scherzer.
Shame it didn't work out.