Was Rotten Apple that bad of an album?

[The God Poster]

I still think Help is/was a dope song

 

[thaKEAF]

The leak and HFM were way better.

 

[imfromthesouthside]

Compared to mainstream albums today it’s like illmatic or ready to die. But In it’s day it had a wack single. I enjoyed it but it’s on the lower end of banks albums and his worst. It was cool to hate g-unit at the time.

 

[LevelUp]

 

[fallback]

Still feel this was a solid album

 

[re'up]

The game had changed too much by then, and they were using the old 2005/2005 formula. The Big Withdraw would have flopped even harder. But, by G-Unit and Banks standards, it's about the same tier as Hunger For More, it's just no one cared anymore.

was going to post this again lol

it was dated already by 2006

but I used to listen to this track way too much and too seriously

 

[Red Money]

Not a good album.

Yayo had a better verse on NY NY than banks, lol.

Hands up, help & get clapped only good tracks, imo.

Too many bad hooks & bad beats. Boring stuff in general.

 

[Womb Raider]

Never really listened to Banks like that but this is hard

 

[Escobar305]

Love survival

 

[7th Letter Specialist]

iceman was my shyt

 

[J-MIL]

I fukked with it like most of Banks releases