I wish I had a Bryan Alvarez drop, because he's say the following sentence perfectly: Buff Bagwell was....fine.
One of the few wrestlers pushed EXACTLY to his skill level with the exception of that stupid WCW Title match with Booker T. It just so happens that his level was kind of over to decently over tag guy/goofy mid-card heel in a main event stable. It's telling that no one is outraged to learn that never held any singles titles. Do you think he really deserved more than that? I don't.
With that said, dude was very solid in the ring before his neck injury (actually very similar to Steve Austin's, believe it or not...remember exactly where I was when I saw it live too). He just...wasn't really that good. But certainly not the worst.