VOTE or DIE: Years later. How do we view Red Dead Redemption 2?

[Saint1]

Hindsight is 20/20

We all played it.
It's grandiose, epic, long and very meticulous.

Does it hold up?
Is it a GOAT?
Did it affect the industry?
How does The Coli view Red Dead Redemption 2?

 

[Dorian Breh]

Hindsight is 20/20

We all played it.
It's grandiose, epic, long and very meticulous.

Does it hold up?
Is it a GOAT?
Did it affect the industry?
How does The Coli view Red Dead Redemption 2?

You would have to pay me to slog through that shyt again

I wouldn't even watch a big titty pawg play it on Twitch

 

[Hopeofmypeople]

An absolute master piece, games being released today still don’t compare to it.

 

[the elastic]

5 Star.


Rockstar need to go ahead and make a movie or TV series.

 

[old pig]

the lowest I would’ve given the game before at the time is 4/5 cuz I wasn’t crazy about the early chapters…but now I’d give it a 5/5 as I take my time and replay it

 

[Doctor Doom]

5/5.

Crazy how both RDR games are Rockstar's best narratively

 

[Methodical]

Easily 5/5 the story mode

I was mind blown when that game came out

Online was okay and got bored quickly. I wish they make a new DLC for the story mode over online bullshyt.

Online kill the DLC

 

[The Pledge]

3/5, shyt felt like a chore to play. RDR1 was a masterpiece, RDR2 felt like Max Payne 3 on horses.

 

[BlackMamba824]

4/5. I wasn't a huge fan of the gameplay (which I probably would give a 3/3.5) but the story was A1

 

[MidniteJay]

4/5. I wasn't a huge fan of the gameplay (which I probably would give a 3/3.5) but the story was A1

This. RDR1 had better gameplay and the multiplayer was fun.

 

[duncanthetall]

It’s a bit clunky but still a fantastic game. 4.5/5

 

[MeachTheMonster]

A boring masterpiece

 

[Big Boss]

Classic

 

[Luke Cage]

Classic.

 

[Food Mane]

The Arthur and the gang story was fantastic, but overall the story got kinda confused. I understand they were trying to illustrate the end of an era/dawn of an era with the new orleans organized crime, the dying indigenous tribe and the actual south american revolution, but all of that is a lot and it felt forced at times. Especially the south american stuff.

If they had stuck with arthur and the gang and made certain gameplay elements less tedious it would be a perfect game