Where did I say it had to contradict what you said but it has already told you that these groups aren't grass movements which proves that the Rebels aren't so much Syrian( very little are). You have ignored the Defector piece in the 2nd link which states "
The Syrian defectors’ story was mostly a useful propaganda piece for western countries — the U.S. specifically — to push people’s attention away from the Islamist extremists who make up the overwhelming majority of the armed struggle. Although there have been a couple of high-level defectors from the Syrian government, they’ve never expanded beyond token amounts, as the unity of the Syrian government continues to testify.
These small amounts of defectors which is extremely small has been pushed as an agenda. No real proof that there are thousands of defectors. That is laughable since the majority of the country supports Assad.
http://www.worldtribune.com/2013/05/31/nato-data-assad-winning-the-war-for-syrians-hearts-and-minds/
1. Saudi Hates Assad.....really? Saudi hates any Arab Country or Muslim country that doesn't follow their rule of law. You contradicted yourself about Saudi hating Assad in your 2nd sentence. Saudi wants a Monarchy Regime in Lebanon and Syria....always wanted that.
2. Chaotic? It's only chaotic that Syrian groups who don't want Saudi Arabia, Qatar, UAE,etc involved can't seem to get their point across except for violence with each other. That isn't a alliance force. Why would Syrian fighters( who you claim are from Syria) attack Christian and Kurdish Villages? If they had beef with the Government why would they attack non-government places?
http://www.alaskadispatch.com/article/20130426/syria-rebels-and-kurds-clash-aleppo
3. So opposition groups were never non-violent. Proves the point of the whole "Arab Spring in Syria"
4. Yes they are coming from elsewhere not just in the Arab Gulf but from Turkey, France, Britain, United States, Balkins, Pakistan, Afghanistan and 12 other countries. Can you name me another so called "Civil War" that allowed these many nations to participate in a conflict with one nation? Plus do you really think that Gulf Governments would just fund Syrians to fight their government. They know that wouldn't work and they would lose.