Too Many Songs, Not Enough Hits: Music Is Struggling to Create New Stars

Monoblock

Smoooth
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
30,479
Reputation
9,817
Daps
118,574
Reppin
Houston
You nikkas love trying to be contrarian thinking you have something to argue about and sound this stupid as a result. Basically what I'm saying is you have no true identity of who the artist is these days and streaming turned music like fast food purchasing ..Folks just drop music and it's forgotten in days because they have no true connection to the audience like that.

Physical media gave you a insight of who the artist is. Fron the artwork, booklets, sampling(which helped me educate me about who did the production, the liner notes, even the lyrics in the booklet. It's why Griselda makes a killing off physical media and why they have a cult following. Sit down somewhere
On point and 100% true. There is nothing to make a connection with artists nowadays due to there being so little physical media, which is why vinyl sales are exploding now. Even if back in the day it was gimmick you still had some type of connection to the artists. Labels would package the music with pics, liner notes, and sometimes lyrics. You not only followed the rappers but the engineers, the mixers, and the actual musicians who played the instruments. Created a whole space and appreciation for music and the art as a whole.
 

DaHNIC82

Veteran
Joined
Jul 20, 2013
Messages
19,317
Reputation
5,199
Daps
84,039
Reppin
Off The Cuff Radio/ScrewballRadio/BudeBoyEnt
On point and 100% true. There is nothing to make a connection with artists nowadays due to there being so little physical media, which is why vinyl sales are exploding now. Even if back in the day it was gimmick you still had some type of connection to the artists. Labels would package the music with pics, liner notes, and sometimes lyrics. You not only followed the rappers but the engineers, the mixers, and the actual musicians who played the instruments. Created a whole space and appreciation for music and the art as a whole.
Facts. Ice T was SHOCKED when I brought him the Home Invasion Physical to sign when I went to his show..

I met a lot of producers, engineers, guitarists, etc just off liner notes. Met Hurt M Badd whom worked on Makaveli. I wouldn't knew who the fukk he was if it wasn't for liner notes.
 

GoldenGlove

😐😑😶😑😐
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
59,486
Reputation
5,725
Daps
140,066
You nikkas love trying to be contrarian thinking you have something to argue about and sound this stupid as a result. Basically what I'm saying is you have no true identity of who the artist is these days and streaming turned music like fast food purchasing ..Folks just drop music and it's forgotten in days because they have no true connection to the audience like that.

Physical media gave you a insight of who the artist is. Fron the artwork, booklets, sampling(which helped me educate me about who did the production, the liner notes, even the lyrics in the booklet. It's why Griselda makes a killing off physical media and why they have a cult following.

:russ: at you bringing up social media like that means shyt. Tell that to Boosie who had 10 million followers but only sold 5k of his last album. You nikkas funny as shyt.
Social media gives us more access to who these people are far more than a physical album booklet. At times it's to an artist's detriment. It pulled the mystic and allure off of artists.

Instead of going through the booklet, fans can go on YouTube and look at a plethora of tutorials for the production process and breakdowns for songs and producers. When an album comes out, artist's do interviews, they drop mini-documentaries, they put out short films... in between releases, they are on social media, posting about current events, sharing their lives etc lol.

The information available now trump's the shyt you're referring back to ten fold. The reason it's harder to make a connection with an artist now isn't because everything is digital. It's harder now because of the increase in options that us as consumers have daily... Which is what the article is saying.
 

winb83

52 Years Young
Supporter
Joined
May 28, 2012
Messages
45,911
Reputation
3,862
Daps
69,483
Reppin
Michigan
right, but in the old paradigm ella mai would've been 99-02 Mya, Summer Walker would be 01-04 Ashanti....sure these women aint working a 9-5 but their overall success, sales, impact, etc is greatly diminished in this new world that's flooded with 40+ ways to consume music and access to literally thousands of artists in their lane. there were merits to having gatekeepers and fewer paths to getting music out in the past, consumers appreciated music more (now it's disposable), the quality was higher, and there was a more collective/communal experience of music.
So the argument is that because the ways and avenues people consume music on has expanded people who were once mid-tier and higher stars can't get the shine they used to? When I was a kid it was MTV, BET, VH1 and radio and that was about it so if a label pushed someone on there it was efficient as the audience had to notice. Now there are so many ways to get music it's difficult to create a new star with just a label push. I would argue stars are created more organically. There's people I've never listened to like NBA Youngboy who are stars from social media. Maybe around the time Justin Bieber came about this started.
 

nieman

Senior Member
Joined
Jun 30, 2012
Messages
17,547
Reputation
2,415
Daps
34,680
Reppin
Philly
Social media gives us more access to who these people are far more than a physical album booklet. At times it's to an artist's detriment. It pulled the mystic and allure off of artists.

Instead of going through the booklet, fans can go on YouTube and look at a plethora of tutorials for the production process and breakdowns for songs and producers. When an album comes out, artist's do interviews, they drop mini-documentaries, they put out short films... in between releases, they are on social media, posting about current events, sharing their lives etc lol.

The information available now trump's the shyt you're referring back to ten fold. The reason it's harder to make a connection with an artist now isn't because everything is digital. It's harder now because of the increase in options that us as consumers have daily... Which is what the article is saying.
They've always done interviews, radio, print, TV appearances, in-store. There was an entire promo run...in addition to doing small venues and chillin with fans after.

Social media is not real - they only show you a glimpse of a cropped version of a moment in their lives. How do you get more from that than reading line notes, seeing them personally thank everyone along their process? How do you get more from that than meeting with them for 20-30mins, having a drink or smoke with them, chopping it up.
 

LiveFromLondon

Superstar
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
7,320
Reputation
351
Daps
17,396
yes, there is an "it" factor, no one is denying that, but every star didn't/doesn't have the "it" factor, and yet still had a major run - toni braxton is someone i'll say wasn't overly charismatic or a person you'd point out and know that's "the one" but she still had wild success, someone like bey on the other hand stood out from jump and/or def by DC's second album as a solo star
I mean i don't find Sean Carter or Nasir Jones all that charismatic outside of the booth but look where they're compared to naturally charismatic guys like Busta and Redman. Cole, Kendrick and even Drake are dull as dish water but are the biggest of this generation with the charisma of a door knob between them.
 

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
61,408
Reputation
8,376
Daps
195,555
Reppin
BX, NYC
no it hasnt. it literally hasnt and this is a crock of shyt.

music today doesnt even have any feeling. majority of this shyt lacks soul. you listen to summer walker music then listen to rnb in the past dont even go to the 70s 80s or 90s just go to amerie’s first album from 02 so much color in the production. the trap influenced music of today is dull and is masked by “bangin” drum programming when the instrumentation itself in the music is lacking because the people making the music shouldnt be making music.
Summer Walker is not a good example.

Over It is one of the legit classic albums with legs that resonated heavily from the last 5 years. It’s also better than Amerie’s album from 02 lol.
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,384
Reputation
3,906
Daps
48,146
Reppin
NULL
How did social media take artist mystique

Because before social media, we heard the music before we even knew anything about the artist. Now, you can go on social media see pictures, videos, and stories of them doing regular everyday routine things. The inside of where they are living, their cars, etc.
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,384
Reputation
3,906
Daps
48,146
Reppin
NULL
Summer Walker is not a good example.

Over It is one of the legit classic albums with legs that resonated heavily. It’s also better than Amerie’s album from 02 lol.

I'd say Summer Walker, in terms of status is like what Amerie was in '02. That album had legs going into 2003 even though it came out in '02. '02 Amerie/Tweet is pretty much the ceiling of the reach that today's "star" has. They had some sizable hits, but they weren't necessarily crossover star/superstar status.
 

GoldenGlove

😐😑😶😑😐
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
59,486
Reputation
5,725
Daps
140,066
They've always done interviews, radio, print, TV appearances, in-store. There was an entire promo run...in addition to doing small venues and chillin with fans after.

Social media is not real - they only show you a glimpse of a cropped version of a moment in their lives. How do you get more from that than reading line notes, seeing them personally thank everyone along their process? How do you get more from that than meeting with them for 20-30mins, having a drink or smoke with them, chopping it up.
You get more because it's literally direct to consumer now. Artists still do small venues and chill with fans. The examples y'all have are not better than what I've seen artists do today in terms of fan engagement.

How about when an artist goes on live and plays fans snippets of unreleased music up to get live feedback? Does this not count? That's not real? How about AMAs with artists?
 

IIVI

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
11,882
Reputation
2,792
Daps
41,233
Reppin
Los Angeles
You got to stand back and look at all this from gen-z's perspective and what's driving them and the rate they consume.

If kids lose their minds for shyt like this, they going to lose their minds over anything else and move to the next thing fast af because there's really nothing there.

No quality product to really be a fan of and stick around when the next in-the-now thing pops up. Everything is vaporware:


Original tweet that got deleted was referring to the video on the right. Group of teenage girls losing their minds for basically nothing at all.



All this shyt got zero staying power. Zero quality. Zero value.

Again, then when there is musical quality somebody simply copies it the next week in their DAWs and starts dropping similar songs straight up sasturating the market.

There is some validity to the whole album artwork, album books, etc. because you can't outright go out there and copy that so quickly, although maybe now you can with A.I generating art.

That's where this shyt is going: A.I going to generate music and visual art.

shyt is a smooth wrap.
 
Last edited:

Renegade47

Superstar
Joined
Mar 2, 2014
Messages
9,828
Reputation
1,966
Daps
31,570
Reppin
North South East West
Summer Walker is not a good example.

Over It is one of the legit classic albums with legs that resonated heavily from the last 5 years. It’s also better than Amerie’s album from 02 lol.
its not better & im talking about the production that shyt does not sound good in comparison. it fits this era but it really is not good.
 

ISO

Pass me the rock nikka
Joined
Mar 12, 2013
Messages
61,408
Reputation
8,376
Daps
195,555
Reppin
BX, NYC
I'd say Summer Walker, in terms of status is like what Amerie was in '02. That album had legs going into 2003 even though it came out in '02. '02 Amerie/Tweet is pretty much the ceiling of the reach that today's "star" has. They had some sizable hits, but they weren't necessarily crossover star/superstar status.
Summer Walker isn’t a crossover superstar but she is a star and is much bigger than Amerie was.

That Amerie album didn’t even make it past Gold.
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,384
Reputation
3,906
Daps
48,146
Reppin
NULL
Summer Walker isn’t a crossover superstar but she is a star and is much bigger than Amerie was.

That Amerie album didn’t even make it past Gold.

Summer Walker is about on par with a 2002 Amerie in terms of success.

Gold in 2002 is far different than gold in 2022. There's really no way to compare the two because Amerie's gold meant at least 500K shipped to retailers. Summer Walker's plaques are a matter of converting the streams into actual sales/shipments. It ain't the same.
 
Top