So you want a return to a world full of wrestling garbage men, police officers, repo men, clowns, barbers, etc., right? You probably want it somewhere in the middle of what it is now and what it used to be.
Like @DANJ! said, at least in the '80s, '90s, early 2000s it was easy to tell the guys apart. Now you just have a whole bunch of people that wear similar trunks (think guys that came from ROH and all happen to have some background in some mixed martial art) or a bunch of guys w/ beards and stern faces.
Yeah... like even back then when WWF was considered "the circus" by "real" wrestling fans... a team like Arn and Tully could come there and do well because they stood out as "no nonsense" guys... also because there wasn't already 3 or 4 other teams there with the same exact look/gimmick. They didn't need to have 10 Arn Andersons in the company when you had one who filled the role well.
I honestly wouldn't mind a lil bit more cartoonish shyt, or some characters that are more fun to watch... they don't need to go back into Bastion Boogers and Mantaurs and Skip & Zip, but gotdamn pal... "tough serious wrestling competitor #3457422" ain't gonna get it either.