This article is interesting
Black trauma porn’: Them and the danger of Jordan Peele imitators
Black trauma porn’: Them and the danger of Jordan Peele imitators
various excerpts from the article:
The true horror of the superficial Amazon show lies in bombarding the audience with scenes of gratuitous, racist violence without having anything interesting to say.
There is an inherent difficulty in producing thoughtful art that comments sensitively on racial violence, dishing up that viscous bigotry as entertainment. In a 2020
Art in America essay, the academic Zoé Samudzi wrote: “Where Blackness is en vogue and atrocity images are a hot commodity, it becomes difficult to produce a commentary or satire that does not read almost identically to the quotidian flows of violence.” The art is, in essence, a continuation of the violence it seeks to represent.
But the
Amazon Studios series Them has no time for such complexity, its creators less like artists struggling to strike a delicate balance between aesthetic, political, and welfare considerations, and more like sadomasochists. The horror anthology, which started with a 10-episode run earlier this month, simply indulges in cheaply exhibiting extremes of Black suffering. It is just the latest effort in what is being described as the “race horror” genre.
If, despite the radically different setting and historical material, this series sounds suspiciously like a sloppy pastiche of Jordan Peele’s critically acclaimed 2019 film
Us, that’s because it is. Or at least it’s meant to be: both centre on the home invasions of a Black family, and the title steal is, frankly, cheeky. But what distinguishes Them from Us is that the established canon of Peele’s work stretches beyond the expected capacities of Black characters in horror films, allowing his actors, in both Us and his 2017 film
Get Out, to revel in the fun and absurdity of the genre.
Where Peele’s work does grapple with racism, in Get Out, it is done so intelligently: attempting to reveal incisive but less visible truths about middle-class liberal racism, that racists can be “Good people. Nice people. Your parents, probably”, as
Lanre Bakare wrote on its release. Them, however, forfeits the opportunity to make any sophisticated or penetrating appraisal of racism in the US beyond affirming its existence. Instead it is an exercise in gratuitous racial violence, both in the infliction of racial terror against the Emory family, and on the Black audience who are left without respite from visceral and degrading scenes.