You're response is very emotional, nobody's saying anyone isn't great. What he is saying is that all races have contributed to the the "sound" of of hip-hop
My response wasn't irrational even if emotion plays a prominent role
in it.
Their contributions are fine but almost all of Hip Hop's musical
foundation was laid by BLACK people and there were no international
contributions to be had during the foundation and most of the evolution of the genre.
Hip Hop is a direct result of the Black American experience and BLACK
American music is most often where it draws it's sources from.
There's no doubt in my mind that Hip Hop has since then gone international
and incorporates the sounds of the locals of whatever country it lands in
but Hip Hop as we generally recognize it and it's chief contributors
are neither Japanese nor "White".
This in no way takes away from Japanese musicians or White Musicians
who have contributed to the genre.
I'm a fan of the producer Nujabes.
I actually like listening to the Japanese rap group Rip slime.
I'm a fan of the producer Alchemist.
I have no problem listening to Apathy, Vinnie Paz, ill bill, El-P, Asher Roth etc.
Let's not twist his intentions, his very first post was to intentionally downplay the talents
of certain individuals and the title of the thread expresses this.
He mentioned prince while totally ignoring that prince eventually fell back on using the
Linn Drum machine because so many people were biting him.
On top of that he (prince) didn't even need the Linn Drum because Prince can and has played the drums on his songs.
I mean we're talking about the same man whose been on the cover of Guitar, Bass, Drum AND Keyboard magazine.
Not to mention the Linn Drum was programmable ! Which kills his goofy argument which concerns prince outright.
He hasn't even mentioned which Drum Machines were/still are used prominently in Hip Hop.
Both the TR-808 AND The Sp-1200 are programmable drum machines !
And we all know (or at least I hope y'all do
) of the SP-1200's place in Hip Hop before more capable machines
came along.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linn_LM-1
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roland_TR-808
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/E-mu_SP-1200
Dude is doing a whole lotta talking and dropping very few examples.