Funny how Pitt could probably be added to this discussion on a talent level with Marino and Revis.
The University of Miami can claim rights to 3 #GOATs at their position in NFL history
- Thread starter Alexander The Great
- Start date
Also, its arguable that STEVE HUCHINSON is the goat Guard
Big Hutch.....above the law
Goat poster
KANG LIFE
I always say those old Canes teams had the most talented teams I've ever seen top to bottom.
With All that Florida talent and somehow they still went and recruited what would become arguably the GOAT Safety from the swamps of Louisiana
With All that Florida talent and somehow they still went and recruited what would become arguably the GOAT Safety from the swamps of Louisiana
@Ed MOTHERfukkING G I don't think anyone would claim Woodson as the GOAT DB
Reed is easily the best Safety I have ever seen play. The only person who could have usurped him was Sean Taylor
That said, I'd listen to an argument for Charles Woodson as the best All-Around DB (safety and CB) to do it.
Add the GOAT dikkriding commentator Mark May and we've got a trilogy
Add Tony Dorsett & Larry Fitzgerald and Pitt lowkey got some all time greats.
Also, its arguable that STEVE HUCHINSON is the goat Guard
HOF soon.
First ballot
Lucky_Lefty
Dreams Are Colder Than Death...
*sighs* Like I said on the pod, ST one of my faves to come out of that shyt factory in Coral Gables but y'all really overstate where his career could've ended up. Hell, going by the stats, Kerry Rhodes was on a higher trajectory since he had more tackles and equal INTs in his first four years as well. Great player but still
nikka we said Ed Reed the Goat
Stinky Diver
attitude as bad as his odor
I had something like 40int's with Sean Taylor in ncaa '04 in one season. Those were the days man
You do know that Sean Taylor never finished his fourth season, right? He basically played three and a half.At the time he died, he was arguably (not in my mind, but still) the favorite to win Defensive Player of the Year that season.
Lucky_Lefty
Dreams Are Colder Than Death...
And don't change the fact Rhodes was right on par with him stat wise up until that point of their careers
At the time he died, he was arguably (not in my mind, but still) the favorite to win Defensive Player of the Year that season.
I'm not saying that Rhodes wasn't good but ... look at it this way. Emmitt Smith is the NFL's all-time leading rusher and rushing touchdown scorer. But no one can convince me he was a better running back than Barry Sanders was, taking each player's apex form.
As a New England Patriot (2007-2012), Wes Welker caught more passes than any other player did during that timespan and had a legit statistical argument as the NFL's best receiver. That said, you couldn't convince me he was the best receiver on his own team (Randy Moss), let alone in the league at that time (Megatron, Brandon Marshall, etc.) taking each player's apex form.
I don't deny that Kerry Rhodes was a stat monster and one of the better safeties in the league at his peak. But at his apex, he was in no way, shape or form better than Sean Taylor at his apex.