The "To trade...or not to trade" Thread

[The Fukin Prophecy]

Jennings ain't coming back till week 10...

Giants play in Seattle week 10 and SF week 11...

So Jennings is pretty much useless till week 12...

 

[THASTUNNA]

pick up Anderson from the Broncos. hillman out 2 weeks

 

[Spliff]

Guy in my league put Kelvin Benjamin on the trade block. I'm tempted to scoop him but don't know who to give up since my team has held me down and taken out the top ranked team last week.

14 team league, half PPR, bonus for 40+ yrd TDs

My squad :

QB: Brady, Cutler
WR: Roddy, Jennings, Welker, Justin Hunter
RB: L. Bell, Lacy, Ingram, Denard Robinson
TE: Kelce, Witten
Def: Miami, Houston

His team:
QB: Big Ben, Tannehill, Cam, Drew Stanton
WR: AJ, Calvin, K.Benjamin
RB: Miller, Sankey
TE: Graham, Gronkowski
Def: Washington, CIN

It's yahoo, so D. Robinson can be played at both WR and RB, and has been beasting accordingly. Normally I just run the 4 RBs and Roddy. Had Allen Robinson as a "just in case" but he on IR now. He runs the two RBs, WRs, TEs.

Khiry Robinson is available in FA. I'm thinking of a Denard + Khiry (persuasion: ingram shoulder may hinder him down the line) package deal.

What would ya'll do @Front 2 Back @The Fukin Prophecy

 

[VBM]

Guy in my league put Kelvin Benjamin on the trade block. I'm tempted to scoop him but don't know who to give up since my team has held me down and taken out the top ranked team last week.

14 team league, half PPR, bonus for 40+ yrd TDs

My squad :

QB: Brady, Cutler
WR: Roddy, Jennings, Welker, Justin Hunter
RB: L. Bell, Lacy, Ingram, Denard Robinson
TE: Kelce, Witten
Def: Miami, Houston

His team:
QB: Big Ben, Tannehill, Cam, Drew Stanton
WR: AJ, Calvin, K.Benjamin
RB: Miller, Sankey
TE: Graham, Gronkowski
Def: Washington, CIN

It's yahoo, so D. Robinson can be played at both WR and RB, and has been beasting accordingly. Normally I just run the 4 RBs and Roddy. Had Allen Robinson as a "just in case" but he on IR now. He runs the two RBs, WRs, TEs.

Khiry Robinson is available in FA. I'm thinking of a Denard + Khiry (persuasion: ingram shoulder may hinder him down the line) package deal.

What would ya'll do @Front 2 Back @The Fukin Prophecy

I'd stand pat and start Roddy and Robinson at WR

 

[bl2k8]

Trying to trade Brady for Jamal Charles probably won't work though

 

[Cracker Jack]

Half PPR league

I get Antonio Brown and Fred Jackson
for Eddie Lacy and Roddy White.

Starters would be Brown, Gordon, Maclin, Ahmad Bradshaw, Ryan Matthews, Dwayne Allen, Flex (Brandon Marshall) Bench Fred Jackson, Frank Gore, ODB

Keep Lacy or make that beast WR core?

 

[The Fukin Prophecy]

Guy in my league put Kelvin Benjamin on the trade block. I'm tempted to scoop him but don't know who to give up since my team has held me down and taken out the top ranked team last week.

14 team league, half PPR, bonus for 40+ yrd TDs

My squad :

QB: Brady, Cutler
WR: Roddy, Jennings, Welker, Justin Hunter
RB: L. Bell, Lacy, Ingram, Denard Robinson
TE: Kelce, Witten
Def: Miami, Houston

His team:
QB: Big Ben, Tannehill, Cam, Drew Stanton
WR: AJ, Calvin, K.Benjamin
RB: Miller, Sankey
TE: Graham, Gronkowski
Def: Washington, CIN

It's yahoo, so D. Robinson can be played at both WR and RB, and has been beasting accordingly. Normally I just run the 4 RBs and Roddy. Had Allen Robinson as a "just in case" but he on IR now. He runs the two RBs, WRs, TEs.

Khiry Robinson is available in FA. I'm thinking of a Denard + Khiry (persuasion: ingram shoulder may hinder him down the line) package deal.

What would ya'll do @Front 2 Back @The Fukin Prophecy

Try to do Kelvin for Denard...Your reasoning for him taking Khiry is

I don't think Denard will keep up his current pace and Kelvin with your scoring system can put up numbers...Only issue is Cam, he's been trash this season...

I also have an interesting dilemma... trade deadline is tomorrow in my league...

My current roster...

Stafford
DT
Julio
Ingram
J Hill
Kelce
Dre Johnson
Edelman

I want to flip Julio and Ingram...ATL is a horribly run team with a shytty QB...I can't go into the playoffs with Julio being used as a decoy in the EZ for Roddy and Hester...

I like Ingram but his workload will decrease when Khiry and Thomas come back...

Would y'all do Julio/Ingram for Sanu/Forte?

 

[The Fukin Prophecy]

Jeremy Hill officially the lead back now which makes him impossible to bench due to volume...

So I Don't know what to do at Rb now...

Was going to start Ingram/Boom/J Stewart but now I'm thinking Ingram/J Hill/Stewart...I really like Boom with JDC out and he's PPR certified...

 

[zopaco317]

Dude in my league is offering Victor Cruz+Jeremy Maclin+one of his bench player for Calvin Johnson cant lie im tempted. He also has Jordan matthews and id rather have him than maclin. Help me out brehs.
My other wideouts are andre johnson, kendall wright, and terrance williams.

 

[VBM]

Dude in my league is offering Victor Cruz+Jeremy Maclin+one of his bench player for Calvin Johnson cant lie im tempted. He also has Jordan matthews and id rather have him than maclin. Help me out brehs.
My other wideouts are andre johnson, kendall wright, and terrance williams.

Cruz is damaged goods. You want no parts of him if you're parting with Calvin. If you're moving Megatron, you better be getting at least a top-10 RB back.

 

[zopaco317]

Cruz is damaged goods. You want no parts of him if you're parting with Calvin. If you're moving Megatron, you better be getting at least a top-10 RB back.

I have forte and mccoy as my rbs. Guess its a no go, thanks for the insight breh.

Take this rep

 

[The War Report]

I have forte and mccoy as my rbs. Guess its a no go, thanks for the insight breh.

Take this rep

If you have those two, why part with Megatron? Makes no sense.

 

[zopaco317]

@VBM @The War Report

This is my first year doing fantasy so im not really sure how these trends go but i got an offer for forte, id be getting Brandon Marshall, James Jones, Melvin Gordon, and donte Moncrief. That seems to good to be true am i missing something?

 

[VBM]

@VBM @The War Report

This is my first year doing fantasy so im not really sure how these trends go but i got an offer for forte, id be getting Brandon Marshall, James Jones, Melvin Gordon, and donte Moncrief. That seems to good to be true am i missing something?

Gotta see what the rest of your squad looks like. I'm always hesitant to give up top flight RBs unless I'm getting a true WR1 in return (I don't think Marshall falls under that category).

 

[zopaco317]

Gotta see what the rest of your squad looks like. I'm always hesitant to give up top flight RBs unless I'm getting a true WR1 in return (I don't think Marshall falls under that category).

QB: Romo/Newton

WR: Calvin Johnson/Andre Johnson/Kendall Wright/Marcus Wheaton

RB: Forte/Mccoy/Lance Dunbar/Tre Mason

TE: Witten/Olsen

Def: Dolphins/Jets

K: Dan Bailey

DP: JJ Watt

I think my WR are lacking and this trade fixes that