Past accomplishments does not matter. We are talking about present day.
Anthony always had good teams and the years the Wolves had good supporting cast they couldn't stay healthy. But I do find it funny that you're bringing up team success when the Knicks currently have the 3rd worst record in the entire league.
You're talking about defense, but does Carmelo play defense? Melo currently plays the 4 and he is barely shooting 44% too. So I don't really get your argument there and Melo is suppose to be this dominant post scorer. Love is currently averaging 24/14/4 on a 500 team. Love is the better rebounder, passer, 3 point shooter, scores at similar rate, not a ball stopper and more importantly he produces more.
So we're supposed to judge a player by 20 games this year rather than what he's consistently showed year after year over 307 games?
Past accomplishments DO matter. You remember Shareef Abdur-Rahim on the Grizzlies? 20 and 10 PF on a garbage team for years. Kings trade for him, thinking they getting an underrated player and come to find out, he was nothing but fool's gold.
Kevin Love is 6'10" 260lbs and a legit PF that can also play Center. Carmelo is 6'8" 235lbs is playing out of position at the 4 spot. He isn't a PF....He's playing there bc there is no one else to play the position effectively on the Knicks
Carmelo is putting up 25 pts, 9 rebs, 2 assts, and 1 stl per game on 44% as a Sf playing out of position at the 4.
Love is putting up 23 pts, 13 rebs, and 4 assts on 43% in his natural spot.
Love is a career loser....Carmelo has never missed the playoffs and only Kobe stopped him from making the Nba Finals in 2009.
The #LWO will become the #LOL if we sit around waiting until the summer of 2015 to throw all our money at a player who's not even a top 10 player in the Nba. He's a great fit for Mike Dantoni offense, yes, but Dantoni won't be here in the 2015 season.
We need a player who can take over on offense on nights that Kobe doesn't have it going in order to compete with Durant and Westbrook....Love ain't him. And also, neither are beasts on defense, however, Carmelo is better on defense than slow foot Love who can't guard 1 on 1 or in the low post to save his life. His low post defense makes Pau Gasol look like a 1st Defensive team player. I don't know who's worse, Kevin Love or Andrea Bargnani on defense. How we gonna DOWNGRADE defensively from Gasol to Love
A non-athletic, non-proven, non-winning, non-post defense, non-efficient PF is what my #LWO brehs are clamoring for?
#LWO
Last edited: