who will win french open

  • nadal

    Votes: 71 38.8%
  • joker

    Votes: 59 32.2%
  • roger

    Votes: 26 14.2%
  • other

    Votes: 27 14.8%

  • Total voters
    183

Carlos Huerta

Just keep my rep red
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
7,004
Reputation
-290
Daps
8,732
Reppin
NULL
Rafa isn't the GOAT over Roger, or even Sampras. He's the clay court GOAT without question, but he's never been as consistent as RF in his prime nor has he been as versatile. If he wins some more other majors, then we'll talk. This is coming from Federer hater (He ruined the excitement of the men's game with his dominance)
Why Sampras? He only won 1 French and Rafa already has as many titles as he does.
 

Regular_P

Just end the season.
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
78,856
Reputation
9,823
Daps
212,205
He has 5 grand slams outside of clay and has made it to 3 AO finals, 5 Wimbledon finals, and 3 US Open finals. How many male tennis players in the Open Era can say that?
Not many. I never said he wasn't an all-time great, but when you're discussing players of that stature, you start splitting hairs. Everyone's opinion is gonna be different, but there's no way I can put him ahead of Federer at the moment.
 

malbaker86

Gators
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
55,852
Reputation
7,015
Daps
124,541
Reppin
Jacksonville, FL
Not many. I never said he wasn't an all-time great, but when you're discussing players of that stature, you start splitting hairs. Everyone's opinion is gonna be different, but there's no way I can put him ahead of Federer at the moment.

Cosign. I have Nadal as my GOAT but I said earlier, I can see how and why Fed is still regarded as the GOAT. It's just a shame how quickly we forget how dominant he was
 

Liu Kang

KING KILLAYAN MBRRRAPPÉ
Supporter
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
13,676
Reputation
5,473
Daps
29,724
Because clay is a quirky surface. We hear about clay court specialists, but not hard/grass court specialists.
Are you serious ?
Never heard of grass courts specialists ? You just grasping for straws at this point. A whole cast of players (let's call them "serve & volley players") feasted on that surface because it fitted their game (same as heavy lifters feasting on clay because it fits). Sampras WAS a grass specialist (same as Roddikk, Henman, Edberg, Becker or Ivanisevic for example) because of his top notch serve and volley game. Anybody who saw the '99 Wimby final against Agassi would told you that this type of game wouldn't have been possible in other surfaces than grass because that was the epitome of grass tennis.

LOL at you dudes "well clay is so special, we shouldn't count the victories on that surface". Clay is NOT a special surface, it's just another surface with its characteristics (high rebound, slow, lift-prone), the same as grass with its characteristics (low rebound, ball having the tendency to burst forth) of same as indoor, same as hard-court, same as carpet... And on every surfaces, you have a different way to move (slightly or not), you skid easier on clay, but you can also on hardcourt. Grass is slippery (remember Wimby '13) so you got to watch your steps and be low to hit the ball. Grass tennis (and indoor / carpet) is (theoretically) fast with short rallies and flatter strokes. Clay tennis is (theoretically) slower with long rallies and you need to give more spin to your balls for it to be more efficient as the rebound "slows" the ball. Tactics are different too as you need different tools to overcome your opponent because the characteristics are different. Hard-court is in the middle somewhere. But no clay is too special so we need to scratch that surface. :snoop:

It's not clay that is too much present, it's grass that is not enough because of the amount of hard-courts everywhere. And also because of the higher cost for grass and clay courts maintenance.
 

Tony D'Amato

It's all about the inches
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
62,201
Reputation
-10,974
Daps
148,256
Reppin
Inches
Maria-Main.jpg



This woman has some sexy azz legs :noah:
 

nomoreneveragain

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
17,448
Reputation
1,440
Daps
29,404
Nadal even got the rules changed, he gets an extra week between Wimbledon and the FO now.

All the Courts play around the same speed now. Thats why I don't prop up Nadal's accomplishments outside Roland Garros
 
Top