Mbappe is a better scorer at the same age. Mbappe is far more versatile offensively. Mbappe cannot be marked by two defenders. You gotta have a shift to guard that nikka. That's Pele/R9 shyt. His ability to play the pass is world-class. His speed is world-class. His speed with the ball is world-class. His dribbling is world-class. His strength is world-class with the ball at his feet, not without the ball of course. His feel for the game is world-class. His passing is world-class when he's focused. That's the area I will give Messi and even CR7 over Mbappe is focus but when Mbappe is focused, you can't do shyt with him and when he wants to carry his team, he does just that, regardless of others. That's not Messi. I've watched too many games where Messi just mopes around the pitch. When he has great squads like this one or the Barca ones, he rarely mopes and is always a threat but I've seen Messi mope a lot, especially his last year at Barca. It wasn't pretty or even last year at PSG.Imma be real, there isn’t any way. You can talk trophy count (Messi already had two champions league medals by MBappe’s age), but Mbappe isn’t the goal scorer Messi was in his prime. Then you look at the complete attacking force Messi was with his passing, dribbling, off the ball runs, maneuvering in tight spaces, etc. MBappe isn’t on that level. And nothing is wrong with that either.
Messi is the GOAT, imo. There is no shame in MBappe not being at that level.
I like my elite players to feel like they are two nikkas on the pitch like you playing 12 on 11. That's what Mbappe is. That's what Pele was. I even loved what Maradona was. He can just carry motherfukkas and make them much better. I never got that feel from Messi. I have always seen him as a finisher or perfect fit when you need to get over. He's not that guy that you just have him carry you. I felt CR7 was better at that. R9 was better at it. Zidane was better at it. Maradona was way better at it. Pele and Mbappe, way better at it. I prefer LeBron. I prefer Tom Brady. I prefer Cam Newton at Auburn. I don't know if it's a personality thing but he's not that guy to me and for me, that's why he ain't that guy as an unquestioned GOAT. Pele is. I like mfers to carry mfers to greatness.