I'm starting to think his Daredevil run was fluke.
Nah, he just lost his fastball after 2004. Happens to a lot of writers.
Look at his early crime/street level/Spider-Man work before Avengers Disassembled, and you'll find a lot of good material there.
Marvel trying to put him on literally every property they had ruined him, mostly because he only really had a voice for criminal/seedy-types and teenagers; once he had to write more conventional superhero comics like New Avengers, he was basically out of his depth and that kind of extended to his other material as well (even his new Jinxworld stuff isn't really on the level of stuff like Jinx and Torso). Dude should probably take a break from writing comics (or at least superhero comics) altogether and recuperate from 15-plus years of overextension, but the industry isn't strong enough to allow for that, and probably never will be again.