If it's just based on resume you might give Hollow the nod but it's always more than that. Whether some on this site agree with the logic or not, a big part of Lux GOAT talk is he is simply clearly just a better rapper than everyone else at the end of the day. No different really than Hollow's versatility putting him in the GOAT convo even though he may not necessarily be the best at any one thing. Lux also has that Calicoe battle, which is still probably the biggest moment in battle rap history, Hollow doesn't have anything like that. Mook was there from the jump and handled his career in a way that makes it easy to call him the GOAT even though I don't think he's an incredible rapper nor has as DEEP of a resume as others (though the battlers he faced, taking into consideration WHEN he faced them, can be put up there with anyone. He killed Lux and Iron Solomon, you can say the battles were garbage and they didn't show up, but those are two of the all time top ten, arguably top fives, who Mook embarrassed. He also has Jae Millz and Serius, who were top of the food chain at that time) Mook also has never been killed in a battle, even if you think he lost a lot they're all debatable. Hollow has at least one clear loss (Arsonal), Mook doesn't have that.I fux with Hollow heavy but not gonna deny he has corny/cringeworthy moments all most every battle.
That being said he deserves to be in talks of goat based on his resume, he never been really killed, takes opponents at top of their height, battled in multipile era's across the country (away games). How does Mook or Lux compare to any of that?
I don't really give extra credit for battling on multiple leagues in this discussion because all three have faced elite comp, Hollow has simply just battled more. And also Hollow has been battling for as long as Mook and Lux, but they were pretty much top dogs from jump, that does say something.
End of the day I see an argument for all three. And I see arguments against all three. I also think these are the only three legitimate GOAT contenders. And I wouldn't be mad at Mook vs. Hollow being looked at as the deciding battle, even though I think it'll be a trash ass battle (nobody looks good against Mook)