The Official 2024 College Football Random Thoughts Thread

DropTopDoc

20/20 Vision With my Buffs On
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
37,772
Reputation
5,690
Daps
77,420
Reppin
South Side Chicago to Nola
Tom Herman 5
Mark Richt 7.5
Willie Taggart 6.5
Kirby Smart 10
Art Briles 6.5
Nick Saban 10
Dabo Swinney 8.5 (trending down)
Les Miles 8 (was hire but his last years were ass)
Ryan Day 8 (last 3 years took him down a full point)
Jim Harbaugh 9 (last 3 years raised him 1.5-2 full points)
David Shaw 7.5
Steve Sarkisian 8
Urban Meyer 10
Brady Hoke 6.5
Rich Rodriguez 4
Chip Kelly 7
Lane Kiffin 8
Will Muschamp 6.5
Brian Kelly 7.5 (never been a fan)
James Franklin 6.5
Kirk Ferentz 7
Gus Malzan 7
Hugh Frese 6
Mack Brown 7.5 (was hire but he's been unimpressive the last 16+ years)
Lincoln Riley 7.5
Dantonio 8 (was hire but his last 2 years the offense was abysmal)
Manny Diaz 6
Dan Lanning 8 (but rising)
Deion Sanders 5.5 (could rise w/ real wins this year)
Doeber 7.5 (not a big fan)
Luke Fickle 8
Narduzi 6


Ok interested in the reasoning for Lincoln and lane number and Mack and BK and Shaw
UCLA should have just went ahead and fired Chip right after the season like they wanted to

Yeah the usc win got him the save
 

skyrunner1

Superstar
Joined
Mar 11, 2022
Messages
6,684
Reputation
1,273
Daps
23,711
Gahdamn them BCS years were stressful af. One L (wasn't safe unbeaten either) and your ass is outta here :pachaha:


Im sure someone has done a video on what 99-13 would have looked like with a 4 team playoff instead of the BCS.
Miami got SCREWED '00!! Santana Moss, Reggie Wayne, Dan Morgan, Al Blades (rip) James Jackson, even Butch Davis ALL deserve to be champions dammit! :mjcry:Would of beat the brakes against them Sooners in Orange Bowl.. That was a dope ass team man..
 
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
13,950
Reputation
6,274
Daps
30,175
Reppin
Chi
Ok interested in the reasoning for Lincoln and lane number and Mack and BK and Shaw


Yeah the usc win got him the save

Was extremely disappointed in SC this year. I had them in the playoffs. I don’t like His defenses.

I probably overrated Lane and underrated BK. I think Ole Miss makes the 12 team playoff this year.

I did this list on the fly so cross comparing them coach to coach will have it looking a little funny (Mack Brown should be an 8)
 

Trav

Marathon Mentality 🏁
Supporter
Joined
May 26, 2012
Messages
29,138
Reputation
5,291
Daps
81,651
Reppin
TMC 8-24
My bad run that post back for me
@DropTopDoc Thoughts on kid and his technique?



Time for an updated list

Tom Herman [6.5] - What a fukkin' fall from grace
Mark Richt [7]
Willie Taggart [5]
Kirby Smart [9.5]
Art Briles [7]
Nick Saban [10]
Dabo Swinney [7]
Les Miles [8.5]
Ryan Day [8]
Jim Harbaugh []
David Shaw [7]
Steve Sarkisian [7] - I need like 1 more yr of dominance from him
Urban Meyer [9.7]
Brady Hoke [😂]
Rich Rodriguez [😂]
Chip Kelly [6.5]
Lane Kiffin [7]
Will Muscham [5.5]
Brian Kelly [7.5]
James Franklin [6.5]
Kirk Ferentz [6.5]
Gus Malzan [7]
Hugh Frese[6.5]
Mack Brown [6.5]
Lincoln Riley [7]
Dantonio [6.5]
Manny Diaz [6] - Much to prove
Dan Lanning [7]
Deion Sanders []
Doeber [7.5]
Luke Fickle [7]
Narduzi [5.5]
...
 

HabitualChiller

Enjoying a Long Night of Solace✌
Supporter
Joined
Oct 27, 2016
Messages
16,336
Reputation
3,678
Daps
50,472
Reppin
Somewhere on an Xbox
Don't know what he did or how bad he was to get fired by Old Dominion midseason in 21' of all places but they got their guy 🔥



Whichever GM that takes McCarthy in the first round needs to be fired as soon as he leaves the office that night.
 
Last edited:

DropTopDoc

20/20 Vision With my Buffs On
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
37,772
Reputation
5,690
Daps
77,420
Reppin
South Side Chicago to Nola

I see no grade for the guy that won a nc

Care to share your thoughts on a few of your grades some seem obvious but expand for me ?

Whichever GM that takes McCarthy in the first round needs to be fired as soon as he leaves the office that night.

Meh, if you want some prospect to put away and build up for a couple years like Jordan love why not ? Mf drafted drew lock and i forget that tall ass mf from Arizona, gms talk themselves all the time into prospects off potential



Couple thoughts

I don’t think he needs perfect ball placement to do work, his catch radius imo is bananas

His route running and eyes hands are crazy, i just remember him on a pass against us, he literally didn’t put his hands up til the ball was there so you understand how good you gotta be, that’s nfl expert level type shyt

Kyle was good, but make no mistake Marv made him look better, idgaf what the qbr or whatever geek stats nikka used

The one part i do agree with and it now makes sense, “want to” Marv don’t have that want to and maybe it’s because he never had a true challenge in college( most dbs can’t check that man), maybe because he knew he was good regardless, he don’t have that killer instinct like his dad (no pun intended) and maybe he decides I’m going to go out there and put his foot in nikkas ass or maybe he does just enough to get by
 

DropTopDoc

20/20 Vision With my Buffs On
Joined
Sep 9, 2012
Messages
37,772
Reputation
5,690
Daps
77,420
Reppin
South Side Chicago to Nola
@DropTopDoc Thoughts on kid and his technique?



He’s Johnny Bravo

He strong up top, legs a bit weak he was getting drove a lot, but he does recover pretty good, he seems to reach a lot, and i saw him hug more nikkas than strike and get his hands on their chest, with some technique he’d be pretty solid
 

Black White Sox Hat

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
60,077
Reputation
4,549
Daps
93,315
You know good and well yall women be walking into public places with them Cookie Monster pajama pants on man. You KNOW that!
You in D Boy country Rigby.You need to be ridin tall,mounted up,fukkin hoes at them little shotgun motels in Opelika snd Phenix City.You scared to mount up?You scared they gonna come take grandma boys shyt?

 
Top