The Official 2024-25 MLB Hot Stove Thread

Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
17,690
Reputation
7,554
Daps
103,061
Reppin
NYC
Pitchers & catchers report today :wow:
9jwvlm.gif
 

tremonthustler1

aka bx_representer
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
83,709
Reputation
9,224
Daps
207,575
Reppin
My Pops Forever RIP
I don't understand the pushback on a cap when a floor would have to be part of that. Look at the current payrolls for the 2025 season:


The average payroll is $154 million. Let's say it bumps up to $160 million when the remaining guys like Bregman sign. There are only 12 teams right now paying more than that. The money will be there.

I also agree that team control needs to be reconfigured. Personally, I think the NHL model would work best for MLB. Baseball players generally don't mature like NBA players and hit the ground running at 19-20. But, that doesn't mean they should get their service time rigged and ferried around the minors until they're 28.

The unrestricted free agency rule for NHL is guys become UFAs no matter what if they are 27 by June 30th or if they've been in the league for seven years (some guys in the NHL are playing at 18). NOBODY likes that most free agents hit the market for the first time in their 30s. If Bregman was a free agent three years ago, he would already be signed to a $200 million deal. He turns 31 at the end of March so teams are hesitant to give him a long term deal. It makes sense, but it's not fair and a terrible system.
Because caps depress salaries. A deal like Soto's would never ever happen even if a team wanted to do so. It took the threat of a grievance by the players to force the A's to go "well look at that, found some money. Gotta spend it somewhere." Those upper level lux penalties actually work. The Dodgers are over it, but they're doing all the gymnastics possible to push back those penalties. The Yankees are scared shytless of the luxury tax. If a cap is gonna somehow make some of these teams spend 2, 3x what they spend now, why not just do it? Baseball is the only spot where theoretically you never have to sign a free agent to field a roster. Some of these teams really apply that and wait for the lux tax checks to come in.
 
Top