The OFFICIAL 2017 College football RANDOM THOUGHTS thread

[Silkk]

Looking at recruiting rankings and stars will tell you exactly who will generally be the best teams this year. Yes, you have 3* players that end up being great, but by and large, the teams with the highest rated players will be the best teams in the country. This is a very well known and unarguable fact.

No the fukk it's not.

Look at what Ole Miss did with all those 5 stars....

Look at what Ron Zook did with all that talent...

Luke fukkel...

Great coaching PLUS talented players is why the top teams are who they are year in and year out.

 

[malbaker86]

Bro u aint even gotta be like that I know yall aint got no other rivalry to fall back on, so you might just be done discussing them period, but u aint gotta try to set up a brick wall on this Auburn discussion

Yall wear our colors, you like our style

 

[Silkk]

who yall got winning the Heisman? i got Lamar Jackson again if L'Ville win 10+ games...

this football porn bruv...

Zero % chance he repeats

Sam Darnold
Derrius Guice
Baker Mayfield if Herman & UT don't shut him down
Lamar will be up there
JT depending on if he stops being a bytch
Random Bama RB

 

[malbaker86]

who yall got winning the Heisman? i got Lamar Jackson again if L'Ville win 10+ games...

this football porn bruv...

Darnold if he doesnt choke

 

[Rigby.]

SEC trash they killed off the Auburn/Florida rivalry

shyt that's what I was talking about couple weeks ago. It makes so much damn sense for us to be the East it's killing me on the inside. Hopefully we win the championship this year just so nikkas ain't say we got excuses

 

[Rigby.]

Yall wear our colors, you like our style

Negro please

Outside of Spurrier, you have no style :nigpls:

 

[Rigby.]

That's the best smiley usage you'll ever see in your time on this forum btw

 

[MustafaSTL]

No the fukk it's not.

Look at what Ole Miss did with all those 5 stars....

Look at what Ron Zook did with all that talent...

Luke fukkel...

Great coaching PLUS talented players is why the top teams are who they are year in and year out.

Ole Miss had a handful of good players. They didn't have a full roster of top 5 recruiting classes. And with that handful of good players they had the most success we've seen from Ole Miss in I don't know how long. Are you serious?

Zook basically had one season with his players being upper classmen. Many of those players ended up being part of the 2006 national championship (thanks for helping prove my point).

And Fickle had one short time for a season with a true freshman at QB.

Look at the past champions, they all have been top 5 classes up and down the roster (OSU, FSU, Bama) or have had good classes with otherworldly level play from the 5* QB (Clemson and Auburn). Again, this is an unarguable fact which I do not understand why you choose to argue against.

 

[Ed MOTHERFUCKING G]

That's the best smiley usage you'll ever see in your time on this forum btw

:madbaugh:

 

[Rigby.]

:madbaugh:

Unless you plan on using this to exemplify the next major display of failure by the American judicial system

 

[Sauce Dab]

Fam...fukk Auburn. Simple as that

:AuMad:

 

[Silkk]

Ole Miss had a handful of good players. They didn't have a full roster of top 5 recruiting classes. And with that handful of good players they had the most success we've seen from Ole Miss in I don't know how long. Are you serious?

Zook basically had one season with his players being upper classmen. Many of those players ended up being part of the 2006 national championship (thanks for helping prove my point).

And Fickle had one short time for a season with a true freshman at QB.

Look at the past champions, they all have been top 5 classes up and down the roster (OSU, FSU, Bama) or have had good classes with otherworldly level play from the 5* QB (Clemson and Auburn). Again, this is an unarguable fact which I do not understand why you choose to argue against.

Not arguing against it, just saying it takes a combo of both.

We've seen coaches win big with less talent more than we've seen shytty coaches win with a lot of talent.

Gary Patterson
Chris Peterson
Chip Kelly
David FN Shaw
Tom Herman
Barney Hoke/Jim Harbaugh

 

[MustafaSTL]

Not arguing against it, just saying it takes a combo of both.

We've seen coaches win big with less talent more than we've seen shytty coaches win with a lot of talent.

Gary Patterson
Chris Peterson
Chip Kelly
David FN Shaw
Tom Herman
Barney Hoke/Jim Harbaugh

How many of those coaches won a national championship?

 

[Silkk]

How many of those coaches won a national championship?

Had TCU not been screwed in 2014, Gary Patterson for sure would've had one


Let me ask you a question though, how many active NCAA coaches have a national title on their resume?

 

[MustafaSTL]

Had TCU not been screwed in 2014, Gary Patterson for sure would've had one


Let me ask you a question though, how many active NCAA coaches have a national title on their resume?

Answer my question first. My entire premise is about winning national championships, and you brought up coaches that have had a few 10 win seasons. Who among those coaches you named without having top 5 classes has won a national championship?