The Offical Rick Grimes Vs. Shane Walsh (TWD Thread)

Shane Or Rick ?


  • Total voters
    41

Jimmy ValenTime

A really good Lawyer
Joined
Jun 2, 2012
Messages
6,357
Reputation
1,490
Daps
13,983
Reppin
The Bronx
I love the actor that plays shane an he performance was great on the show

but a character like shane would not go to live long in that world cause he doesn't inspire other s to have his back

rick not a great planner but he does as much as he can for people and that inspires them to look out for him ie daryl and michionne
 

gluvnast

Superstar
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
9,729
Reputation
1,529
Daps
27,761
Reppin
NULL
Shane. And fukk that excuse about simpin Lori. RICK stuck with that ho ass.

The point is what Rick EVOLVE to now was what Shane already was. The real issue back then wasn't even about Lori, but two alpha males fighting for control. But everything Rick was suggesting was ignorant and naive whereas Shane was making the most sense to which NOW Rick adapted to.
 

duckbutta

eienaar van mans
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
38,701
Reputation
10,100
Daps
148,900
Reppin
DFW
Rick has turned into Shane so :francis:

I actually quit watching this show after they offed him...he was one of the few characters I didn't find annoying :francis:

If Carol had slowly morphed into semi :demonic: I would have stopped watching completely
 

gluvnast

Superstar
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
9,729
Reputation
1,529
Daps
27,761
Reppin
NULL
Rick. Shane would throw you into zombie infested bushes for p*ssy: clean or not. Simp ass fukk boi.:scust:

Current:demonic:OG Carol might have killed that man, if she caught wind of his psychotic simping bullshyt. :laugh:

Shane was the reason why the colony even SURVIVED in the 1st place. The majority of the the original crew is dead because of Rick.

The only thing you have against Shane is Lori ho ass like we gonna pretend Rick was fighting for the same puss. fukk that ho. At the same time, Rick shouldn't of use that as leverage over him. That clan was doing okay until he came in and took over.

Now 6 seasons later, RICK understood what SHANE was schooling him all along.
 

Sypress

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
12,042
Reputation
3,501
Daps
37,948
:dead: if Shane is a simp for chasing after Lori, what does that make Rick for keeping her?

Shane understood the world they once knew didn't exist anymore. Survival of the fittest
 

EarlyMaridia

All Star
Joined
Feb 15, 2014
Messages
924
Reputation
290
Daps
2,694
Shane was the reason why the colony even SURVIVED in the 1st place. The majority of the the original crew is dead because of Rick.

The only thing you have against Shane is Lori ho ass like we gonna pretend Rick was fighting for the same puss. fukk that ho. At the same time, Rick shouldn't of use that as leverage over him. That clan was doing okay until he came in and took over.

Now 6 seasons later, RICK understood what SHANE was schooling him all along.

That was his wife. :heh: Shane was so emotionally distraught over a girl that wasn't his that he tried to rape her and throw his main main in the bushes over her. He deserved several shells for still trying to play dad when Rick came back.

Six seasons later and Rick has brought them through way more bullshyt than Shane ever had to deal with. Shane would have gotten killed and his squad wiped by the Governor over vagina.

Shane also let a racist run his squad too. Rick wasn't having that shyt. :banderas:
 

gluvnast

Superstar
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
9,729
Reputation
1,529
Daps
27,761
Reppin
NULL
That was his wife. :heh: Shane was so emotionally distraught over a girl that wasn't his that he tried to rape her and throw his main main in the bushes over her. He deserved several shells for still trying to play dad when Rick came back.

Six seasons later and Rick has brought them through way more bullshyt than Shane ever had to deal with. Shane would have gotten killed and his squad wiped by the Governor over vagina.

Shane also let a racist run his squad too. Rick wasn't having that shyt. :banderas:

How many times I have to tell you the beef between them wasn't about Lori. That ho was a scapegoat. The reason was who wanted to be leader and Rick felt Shane was unfit and used to Lori angle as the excuse.
 

Chris Cool

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jun 22, 2014
Messages
30,916
Reputation
7,036
Daps
109,009
Reppin
So Cal
That was his wife. :heh: Shane was so emotionally distraught over a girl that wasn't his that he tried to rape her and throw his main main in the bushes over her. He deserved several shells for still trying to play dad when Rick came back.

Six seasons later and Rick has brought them through way more bullshyt than Shane ever had to deal with. Shane would have gotten killed and his squad wiped by the Governor over vagina.

Shane also let a racist run his squad too. Rick wasn't having that shyt. :banderas:
Shane had moved on until lori came back to him spewing that bullshyt, that bytch was the worst. now Rick stuck with Lil baby Shane
 

Manofsteel

Rookie
Joined
Oct 20, 2015
Messages
179
Reputation
-80
Daps
185
I'm going with Savage Rick, i like the way he's been developed on the show
 

marcuz

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
55,000
Reputation
12,801
Daps
157,156
Shane. And fukk that excuse about simpin Lori. RICK stuck with that ho ass.

The point is what Rick EVOLVE to now was what Shane already was. The real issue back then wasn't even about Lori, but two alpha males fighting for control. But everything Rick was suggesting was ignorant and naive whereas Shane was making the most sense to which NOW Rick adapted to.
wrong, rick still cares about his group. shane never gave a fukk about anyone outside of lori and carl
 
Joined
Feb 27, 2015
Messages
7,505
Reputation
1,250
Daps
32,865
I have to say Rick, yes he is what Shane is now but what sets him apart from Shane is that Rick will go to war for you. Remeber when those cops kidnapped Beth? What Rick said? "We go in under the cover of night and slit they throats no gunfire" :demonic:

Shane would have let beth rot or have Daryl go alone to save her.

Shane was a selfish savage
Rick is a savage who will have your back no matter what, that been said those two togather now? Shiiiit they would run half of Georgia by now. Governor would be dead off top, the cannibals would be burned alive in thier town and the wolves would be some poodles by now:wow:
 

marcuz

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
55,000
Reputation
12,801
Daps
157,156
Shane was the reason why the colony even SURVIVED in the 1st place. The majority of the the original crew is dead because of Rick.

The only thing you have against Shane is Lori ho ass like we gonna pretend Rick was fighting for the same puss. fukk that ho. At the same time, Rick shouldn't of use that as leverage over him. That clan was doing okay until he came in and took over.

Now 6 seasons later, RICK understood what SHANE was schooling him all along.

shane so called kept the group alive because nothing was popping yet. he went into the hills, where their were no zombies, and survived for ~3 weeks. keeping in mind, shane was going to leave glenn and the others to die in atlanta.

rick on the other hand, has been doing this shyt for over 2 yrs. so yeah, what type of bullshyt comparison are you making? and really, there's a decent chance all of the shanes group would have died if rick didn't come back with a duffle bag full of guns.
 

marcuz

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
55,000
Reputation
12,801
Daps
157,156
Shane would have let beth rot or have Daryl go alone to save her.

to be real, the entire group would have been different under shane.

shane wanted to take over the farm by force = so no hershel, maggie, beth

shane wanted to leave glenns group trapped in atl = so no glenn, andrea, t-dogg, merle

shane didn't want to go back and rescue merle = so no daryl

shane wasn't fond of dale, so he probably would have killed him

shane didn't give a fukk about carol or sophia, so there's a good chance she wouldn't be alive or apart of the group anymore


really, under shane, it would just be lori and carl.
 
Top