Lol @ justifying hate watching now.... I'm going to dismantle this poor logic on here real quick. To me, NXT is still the best weekly wrestling show on TV. It has pretty much everything I want out of wrestling because it's a very good mix of story telling and workrate combined with some ridiculous backstage stuff and dope characters.
WWE is presenting it as a 3rd brand again. They routinely have main roster talent on, all the key signings are going through NXT first, they are taking it on the road again, etc.
I don't use outdated metrics to say whether it's "successful" or not but let's look into it. After the first couple weeks, the show is now sitting around 600k viewers on a national broadcast station. It does around 0.19 in the key demos.
If I was to sit here and discuss those metrics for it, is it doing well... The CW is in every single household in the United States. NXT was doing pretty much the same numbers on cable as it is now on broadcast TV with ~40 million more homes that have the opportunity to watch it. Their second show in St. Louis was supposed to be in a 15,000 capacity arena and they moved it to a 1500 capacity setting because tickets weren't selling.
Does any of this affect my enjoyment of the show? Absolutely not...
Does it even matter what they do on The CW? Not really, no... because they have a lengthy contract that's bringing in more TV rights media money than ever before.
Do people even discuss what it's doing on a weekly basis? Nope. Because these AEW discussions were never about "success".. they are about stanning something.. It's always been about being a stan.
Do people discuss how SD! lost 700,000 weekly viewers when they moved from FOX to USA? No, because that's again broadcast vs. cable and also SD! got their money anyway from USA... it was a big increase.
From an objective standpoint, it doesn't matter what the AEW ratings on TBS are either and when they are simulcast on Max in January, we will have no clue how many people are actually watching the product.