I had to remember to list the reasons in my reply LOL
Yeah I've noticed we don't do enough of that when we're voting on this shyt. The people who say "yes" don't always give their reasons why other than "my childhood" or some choice quotes from the flick while the people who say no don't say why it's a no.
The point of this thing was to foster some discussion around flicks that someone else holds near and dear and truly deciding whether we believe this thing is one of the greatest movies of all time for whatever your reasons are. Or whether you think it's good but not a part of that upper echelon conversation.
We're a smart bunch, so this shouldn't be a thing for us.